Tuesday, October 8, 2024

Hossenfelder: The 2024 Nobel Prize in Physics Did Not Go To Physics -- This Physicist is very surprised

Hossenfelder comments: "A quick comment on the 2024 Nobel Prize in physics which was awarded for the basis of neural networks and artificial intelligence. Well deserved, but is it physics?" She also wonders if this does't reflect (what she regards as) the dismal state of current work in the foundations of physics and points out that physicists have been using neural networks for years as tools.

Herbert Simon won the Nobel Prize in Economics in 1978 for "for his pioneering research into the decision-making process within economic organizations." The Nobel Committee did not mention his work in Artificial Intelligence. But would he have gotten the prize without that work? 

* * * * *

Gary Marcus has an interesting post on the physics Nobel, for AI, and the chemistry as well: Two Nobel Prizes for AI, and Two Paths Forward:

Let’s start with Hinton’s award, which has led a bunch of people to scratch their head. He has absolutely been a leading figure in the machine learning field for decades, original, and, to his credit, persistent even when his line of research was out of favor. Nobody could doubt that he has made major contributions. But the citation seems to indicate that he won it for inventing back-propagation, but, well, he didn’t.

He goes on spell out a more detailed history of early work in neural nets, citing remarks by Steven Grossberg and Jürgen Schmidhuber.

1 comment:

  1. I don't know how to judge my own laugh when I saw the announcement. A nod to the absurdities?

    ReplyDelete