Meeting of Minds: Elizabeth I, Jane Austen, Jackie Kennedy

It’s time for another MEETING OF MINDS, based, of course, on Steve Allen’s old TV show, Meeting of Minds. This is where Claude 3.5 gets to enact a conversation between three people who never, in fact, could possibly have met in real life. We kicked off the series with an old time good one, as Satchmo used to say, three [robots] walked into a bar, in this case, Robbie, HAL, and C3PO. Then I decided that we had to get real, so I staged a meeting between Archimedes, Goethe, and Musk.

Now it’s time to get even more real, with a conversation between three powerful women, Queen Elizabeth I of England, Jane Austen, and Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis. This conversation developed in stages. I gave Claude 3.5 Sonata a prompt, a rather long one, and then it got back to me. Claude would chatter on for a bit, then stop and ask me what I wanted to do next. I tell them and off we’d go again.

* * * * *

A Meeting of Minds: Three Women of Influence

Setting: The drawing room of Jane Austen's home in Chawton, Hampshire, during the Regency period. The room is modestly furnished but comfortable, with a writing desk by the window. Jane Austen is serving tea to her distinguished guests: Queen Elizabeth I and Jackie Kennedy Onassis.

JANE AUSTEN: (arranging tea cups) Your Majesty, Mrs. Onassis, I cannot express what an honor it is to host you both in my humble home. I must confess, I find it fascinating that we three have such different experiences with marriage – or the lack thereof.

ELIZABETH I: (with characteristic directness) Indeed, Miss Austen. I see you, like myself, chose to remain unmarried. Though I suspect your reasons differ from my own.

JACKIE KENNEDY: (elegantly stirring her tea) And I married twice – though neither marriage was quite what the public imagined. I've always been intrigued, Your Majesty, by your famous speech about being "married to England." Was that truly your feeling, or merely skilled political rhetoric?

ELIZABETH I: Both, Mrs. Kennedy, as any woman in power must understand. When I told Parliament I was "already bound unto an husband, which is the kingdom of England," I spoke truth. Yet I also spoke strategy. You both understand, I think, how men seek to control women through marriage.

JANE AUSTEN: (wryly) In my novels, I try to show that marriage should be a matter of both affection and prudence. Yet I've observed that even the happiest marriage requires a woman to surrender much of her independence.

JACKIE: (thoughtfully) Independence... yes. Even as First Lady, I fought to maintain some measure of privacy, of self. The public eye can be its own form of cage, whether you're a queen, a president's wife, or a celebrated author.

ELIZABETH I: (leaning forward intently) Precisely. Miss Austen, you shield yourself through your wit and irony. Mrs. Kennedy, you created your mystique through careful control of your public image. And I – I wielded my unmarried state as both sword and shield.

JANE AUSTEN: Yet you both lived in worlds so much grander than my quiet corner of Hampshire. I observed humanity through a little bit of ivory, as I once said.

JACKIE: But through that lens, you captured universal truths about marriage, ambition, and society that resonated even in my time, two centuries later.

ELIZABETH I: (with a sharp smile) And in doing so, Miss Austen, you achieved a form of immortality without ever wearing a crown. Though I notice you never wrote a queen as your heroine.

JANE AUSTEN: (with a small bow) How could any fictional queen compare to Your Majesty? But tell me, Mrs. Kennedy, you knew both immense power and immense tragedy. How did you maintain your dignity through it all?

[The dialogue continues as the three women explore themes of power, privacy, public perception, and the prices they each paid for their choices...]

JACKIE: (thoughtfully) Dignity... it was armor, really. When they assassinated Jack, I remembered thinking of you, Your Majesty – how you survived so many attempts on your life, yet maintained your strength. I told myself, "Jackie, you must be a queen now." I even studied your speeches.

ELIZABETH I: (with unexpected gentleness) You did more than survive, madam. The way you led your nation in mourning, walking with such grace behind your husband's casket – it showed more royal bearing than many born to the purple.

JANE AUSTEN: (quietly) We each created our own forms of armor, did we not? Your Majesty had your image of the Virgin Queen, Mrs. Kennedy had her pillbox hats and perfect composure, and I... I had my irony and my fictitious worlds.

ELIZABETH I: Yet your wit was as sharp as any sword, Miss Austen. "For what do we live, but to make sport for our neighbors, and laugh at them in our turn?" You wrote that, did you not? I would have enjoyed such honest observations at my court.

JACKIE: (smiling) I tried to read Pride and Prejudice to Caroline when she was young. I wanted her to understand that a woman could be both strong-minded and feminine. Though I suspect Elizabeth Bennet might have found the White House as confining as I sometimes did.

JANE AUSTEN: (with a hint of mischief) Not all prisons have visible bars, do they? Your Majesty rejected marriage to keep your power, Mrs. Kennedy married into power but found it a gilded cage, and I... well, I chose a different kind of freedom altogether.

ELIZABETH I: (sharply) Freedom! I wore my freedom like a crown, yet every day I had to prove myself twice as capable as any man. Even now, centuries later, they debate whether I truly wrote my speeches, handled my own diplomacy.

JACKIE: They still underestimate us, don't they? They called me frivolous for redecorating the White House, never understanding I was creating a symbol of American culture and history. Just as they dismissed your novels as mere romantic tales, Miss Austen.

JANE AUSTEN: (setting down her teacup with precision) Indeed. Your Majesty created an entire era, Mrs. Kennedy defined American elegance for a generation, and I... I merely wrote about three or four families in a country village.

ELIZABETH I: (with a knowing smile) Yet in those families, you captured the same battles for power, position, and autonomy that I fought in my court. The weapons were words and manners rather than armies and navies, but the stakes were just as real to those who fought them.

JACKIE: Speaking of battles... How did you both manage the men who thought they could guide your choices? The advisors, the suitors, the well-meaning friends?

JANE AUSTEN: (archly) I made them into characters. Mr. Collins still makes readers laugh, two centuries later.

ELIZABETH I: (laughing) I made them into courtiers - kept them dancing attendance while I followed my own counsel. "I may not be a lion, but I am a lion's cub, and I have a lion's heart."

JACKIE: (with subtle humor) I smiled and wore my pearls and did exactly as I pleased. Sometimes the perfect outfit is also armor.

ELIZABETH I: (contemplatively) Miss Austen, your heroines seek marriages of true companionship - a luxury rarely afforded to women of my time. Marriage then was statecraft, nothing more. Even my sister Mary's marriage was merely a political tool.

JANE AUSTEN: (earnestly) Yes, I wrote of what I hoped marriage could be - a partnership of equals in mind and temperament. Though even in my time, that remained more ideal than reality for most.

JACKIE: (thoughtfully) And in my era, we were sold the perfect marriage as a dream - the husband with his career, the wife making a beautiful home. But beneath that perfect surface... (she pauses) Well, let's just say I understand why you chose to rule alone, Your Majesty.

ELIZABETH I: Yet you remarried, Mrs. Kennedy. A choice few women of my rank would have dared.

JACKIE: (with quiet firmness) Because by then I had learned to make choices for myself, not for the world. Though the press never forgave me for it. They wanted me to remain America's eternal widow.

JANE AUSTEN: (observing keenly) How fascinating that in my novels, marriage is the beginning of happiness, yet in both your lives, refusing or ending marriages became acts of self-determination.

ELIZABETH I: (with steel in her voice) Because marriage has ever been about power, Miss Austen. Whether it's a queen's political alliance, a society woman's security, or your heroines' search for compatible minds - the question is always who holds the power.

JACKIE: And even in my time, with all our supposed progress, a woman's power was still so often defined by her relationship to men - someone's wife, someone's widow, someone's mother...

JANE AUSTEN: (wryly) At least as a spinster authoress, my power, limited though it was, remained my own. Though I notice, Mrs. Kennedy, that you kept your first husband's name even after remarrying. Another kind of power?

JACKIE: (with a slight smile) The name was armor too, of a sort. Though I sometimes wondered if it was also a cage. Your Majesty never had to navigate being known by a man's name.

ELIZABETH I: No, but I had to carry my father's. 'King Henry's daughter' - both blessing and curse. At least your father was not known for beheading your mother, Mrs. Kennedy.

JACKIE: (soberly) Speaking of troubled royal marriages, I've often thought of that poor Princess Diana. The parallels were... uncomfortable. Another young bride thrust into a spotlight she couldn't have truly understood.

ELIZABETH I: (with sharp interest) Ah yes, the Spencer girl. Wed to my successor's heir. I followed these events with... particular attention. A royal marriage that nearly brought down the monarchy - precisely what I feared might happen in my own time.

JANE AUSTEN: (thoughtfully) She wanted the marriage I wrote about in my novels - a love match. Instead, she found herself in the kind of political alliance that dominated Your Majesty's era. The worst of both worlds, perhaps?

JACKIE: (with quiet intensity) The public's appetite for her was... insatiable. I recognized that hunger. They wanted a fairy tale princess, just as they wanted their perfect widow from me. But Diana... she found a way to turn that appetite to her own purpose.

ELIZABETH I: (shrewdly) Yes, she wielded the public's love as skillfully as I once wielded Parliament's fear. Though it won her few friends at court, I imagine.

JANE AUSTEN: (observing carefully) From what I understand, she broke with tradition - aired the family's private struggles publicly. In my time, that would have been unthinkable.

JACKIE: (with understanding) Sometimes speaking out is the only power left to you. Though I chose silence, I understood her choice to speak. The world had changed since my time as First Lady.

ELIZABETH I: (with dry amusement) In my day, we simply imprisoned troublesome relatives in the Tower. Much more straightforward. Though I speak in jest... well, mostly in jest.

JANE AUSTEN: It seems no matter the era, a woman who defies expectations pays a price. Whether she's a queen refusing to marry, a widow refusing to fade gracefully away, or a princess refusing to suffer quietly.

JACKIE: (softly) The price of being in the public eye hasn't changed as much as we might wish. Just the methods of scrutiny. From court gossips to newspaper photographers to... what do they call them now? Paparazzi.

ELIZABETH I: (thoughtfully) Yet each of us found ways to shape our own story. I transformed myself into Gloriana, the Virgin Queen, married to her country. A role of my own making.

JANE AUSTEN: (with quiet satisfaction) While I chose to publish anonymously - "By a Lady." Though now, centuries later, it seems my name has rather got out.

JACKIE: (smiling) And I learned to let them photograph the image I chose to present - the perfect mother, the guardian of culture, the keeper of the flame. The real Jackie remained private, behind that image.

ELIZABETH I: (with sudden intensity) "I know I have the body of a weak and feeble woman, but I have the heart and stomach of a king, and of a king of England too." I spoke those words before the Armada, and they are remembered still. That is power - to choose the words by which history knows you.

JANE AUSTEN: (thoughtfully) I let my characters speak for me. "I hate to hear you talk about all women as if they were fine ladies instead of rational creatures." Words given to Mary Crawford, yet they were mine too.

JACKIE: (reflectively) I rarely gave interviews, but I spoke through my actions - preserving the White House, protecting my children's privacy, building a life on my own terms after Jack's death. Sometimes silence itself is a form of authorship.

ELIZABETH I: (rising regally) Well said, all. It seems that whether queen, author, or First Lady, a woman must write her own story - or others will write it for her.

JANE AUSTEN: (beginning to clear the tea things) Though I must say, having my story written by others has worked out rather well in my case. They've even made me into rather a romantic heroine - I who never married!

JACKIE: (with gentle amusement) They tried to write me as a tragic heroine. I preferred to be the editor of my own life.

ELIZABETH I: (moving to the window) And I... I chose to be both author and subject of my story. "This is the Lord's doing, and it is marvelous in our eyes." Those were my first words as queen, and I made sure they were not my last.

JANE AUSTEN: (glancing at the setting sun) Speaking of last words... I believe our time grows short. But what a remarkable thing - to have shared these thoughts across the centuries.

JACKIE: (preparing to leave) Each of us living in such different times, yet facing the same essential challenge - to remain ourselves despite all that the world demanded of us.

ELIZABETH I: (with final authority) And succeeding, each in our own way. For is that not the true measure of a life well lived?

[The late afternoon sun streams through the windows of Jane Austen's drawing room as the three women rise, each having shared in this remarkable meeting of minds across time, each having forged her own path through the constraints of her era, each having, in the end, written her own story.]