Showing posts with label Robert_Wright. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Robert_Wright. Show all posts

Monday, November 9, 2026

Strogatz talks about AI and math with Robert Wright

YouTube page:

Robert Wright and Cornell mathematician Steven Strogatz—co-author of the new book Big Math: The Hidden Codes That Run Our World—discuss how AI is upending math and whether human insight is becoming obsolete—and how the roots of big math go back much further than the advent of the large language model.

0:00 Teaser
0:37 Steve’s new book, Big Math: The Hidden Codes that Run Our World
4:04 What is “big math”? And why do we need it?
11:46 The key to the neural network’s power
18:33 AI’s black box problem
23:52 Is human insight going extinct?
32:34 How math has continually changed humanity
43:07 Insight via 100 ants
51:17 The intersecting origins of network theory and a jazz legend
57:34 Heading to Overtime

Friday, October 23, 2026

On our place in the universe: the Anthropocene, Gaia, and the noosphere

Robert Wright and Boris Shoshitaishvili discuss Boris’s new book, Our Planetary Mirror, which draws on three big ideas—Gaia, the noosphere, and the Anthropocene—along with philosophy and myth to reassess who we are and the problems we face as a species. Overtime: Are humans AI’s fossil fuel?

0:00 Overtime teaser
0:43 Boris’s background and new book, Our Planetary Mirror
3:43 Three ways of seeing the planet—and us
12:47 Resurveying the Gaia “hypothesis”
20:31 Dawkins’s case against Gaia
27:16 Is humanity outgrowing its planetary parent?
32:57 The noosphere: Teilhard vs Vernadsky
48:46 Can we reason our way to global solidarity?*
53:58 Heading to Overtime

*This section has tantalizing hints about the need for a symbolic and mythological dimension to our conception of our place in the universe.

Monday, October 12, 2026

Robert Wright interviews Alex Gibney on his Musk documentary

Robert Wright and filmmaker Alex Gibney discuss Alex's epic new documentary about Elon Musk—an exploration of how the world's richest man got so powerful (and so weird).

0:00 Teaser
0:32 Alex’s new documentary about Elon
3:07 How Alex’s film turned epic
7:10 Simulation theory + social Darwinism = Elon?
13:36 Inside the mind of Musk
23:46 Elon’s daddy issues
26:35 Elon’s lady issues
29:14 Elon’s electoral propriety issues
36:58 Has Elon gotten weirder over time?
46:42 The damage DOGE could still do
50:14 Heading to Overtime

Discussed in Overtime:
Elon’s Trumpian side.
Is Elon a hypocrite on AI?
All-In on the Twitter-DOGE playbook.
Are Elon and Trump the new normal?
The time Bob interviewed Elon.

Sunday, August 23, 2026

Why did Robert Wright (have) to drink the Silicon Valley Kool Aid? [GT-6]

I thought that, when I’d posted notice of my 3 Quarks Daily review of Robert Wright’s The God Test that that was that. But then I read his interview with Liron Shapira, AI Dystopia Is Just 8 Years Away — Robert Wright, Bestselling Author of “The God Test.” Whoops! There’s that phrase again.

The phrase I’m talking about is “reverse engineer.” I believe that the term has been kicking around in psychology for several decades, but I associate it with Steven Pinker’s 1997 book, How the Mind Works (pp. 21-22:

Reverse-engineering is what the boffins at Sony do when a new product is announced by Panasonic, or vice versa. They buy one, bring it back to the lab, take a screwdriver to it, and try to figure out what all the parts are for and how they combine to make the device work. We all engage in reverse-engineering when we face an interesting new gadget. In rummaging through an antique store, we may find a contraption that is inscrutable until we figure out what it was designed to do. When we realize that it is an olive-pitter, we suddenly understand that the metal ring is designed to hold the olive, and the lever lowers an X-shaped blade through one end, pushing the pit out through the other end. The shapes and arrangements of the springs, hinges, blades, levers, and rings all make sense in a satisfying rush of insight.

With that in mind, let’s look at some remarks Wright made to Liron:

Even so, what this approach to training does is, I think, replicate specific cognitive functionality in these machines that exist in the human mind. I don’t mean it does things exactly the way the human mind does. These models have independently invented things that natural selection invented. Edge detection’s a very clear case.

Wright doesn’t use the phrase there, but that’s what he has in mind. Here Wright uses the phrase:

... but even with the current paradigm, you give it kinds of data, visual, auditory, written, whatever, and it basically reverse engineers parts of the human mind that do the transmutation of one form of data into another.

There’s the key phrase. Here’s one last passage. The phrase isn’t here, but the idea certainly is:

You just make the machine good at predicting the next sequence of letters. When you first show it the stuff, it’s pure gibberish, but the machine itself finds a way of mapping the meaning. We do give it the basic... We do say you gotta use vectors to represent the words. It didn’t invent that. But we didn’t say, “By the way, you should choose numbers to fill in the blanks in the vectors that capture this thing we call meaning.” No, it in effect discovered that meaning is a property of words. I would put it that way.

NO.

It’s one thing to talk about psychologists “reverse engineering” bits of human behavior. I have no problem with that. But that’s not what Wright is doing here. He’s talking about machine learning, about transformers, reverse engineering human language and cognition. That’s not at all a useful way of conceptualizing what’s going on. It’s anthropomorphizing. It’s also the kind of mystification that Silicon Valley has been using to hype AI.

Once again I refer you to Berk Idem’s review, where he notes:

My problem is the road he takes in the book. Wright keeps telling the story of AI as if the machines discovered things on their own, that they found the meanings of words, that they grew something like an eye, that they started to evolve, when in fact people set almost all of the machinery up on purpose, with a pretty clear idea of what they were doing and why. I never expected myself to be on the “intelligent design” side of a debate, yet here I am, for instance, arguing that LLMs did not miraculously discover meaning, they were designed to do that. Wright gives too much credit to what models discover during training and too little to the architecture, objective, and research program that produced those discoveries.

Idem is correct. You should consult his review for more details, but I’ll say a couple of words about edge detection in vision and the meaning of words.

Back in 1959 Hubel and Wiesel published their seminal work on the visual cortex of the cat, work that led to their 1981 Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine. Virtually all work in machine vision has been informed by that study in one way or another. Machine vision systems are engineered to be sensitive to edges.

The same is true for language. It simply is not true that transformers “in effect discovered that meaning is a property of words.” There is a long tradition within linguistics and computational linguistics of thinking about the meanings of words as a function of the contexts in which words are used, something I review in a recent working paper, The Origins of LLMs – A long tectonic subduction event finally producing a visible volcanic eruption in November 2022 (the subtitle was suggested by ChatGPT). The idea dates back to the 1950s while its computational exploitation dates back to work that Gerard Salton began in the late 1960s on information retrieval. He’s the one who came up with the idea of using vectors to represent linguistic meaning. The transformer is thus a recent elaboration of an idea that’s been around for decades, an idea that human researchers came up for conceptualizing meaning.

* * * * *

There’s much more in Wright’s interview with Liron, much of it interesting. And some of it is bothersome, but I’ve said enough on that score. The God Test is an interesting book. But be careful of what Wright attributes to the machine. You’re better off having no explanation than accepting one that’s misleading at best.

Wednesday, August 12, 2026

Gort, Robert Wright, and A.I. @3QD [GT-5]

My latest 3 Quarks Daily article is up:

Klaatu barada nikto: Robert Wright’s The God Test

It’s a review of Robert Wright’s current book, The God Test. It turned out to be a tough slog, more than I’d anticipated.

I started blogging about it well ahead of time. I figured I’d write a half-dozen to ten or so blog posts ahead of time and then wrap things up with the formal review. I wrote some blog posts, but by Tuesday, August 4, less than a week before my article was due, I was still blogging about coming up with an approach and hadn’t gotten around to the various things I wanted to cover in the lead-up. Then the weekend arrived and I had to start writing. So I did, here and then. But things wouldn’t converge. Still, I managed to write something and post it on Sunday afternoon. But I wasn’t happy.

Of course, while sometimes I’m satisfied with my 3QD pieces, that’s not always so. This was just one of those times. But still.

On Monday, when the piece actually appeared, I thought I had one of those situations I often had as an undergraduate. I’d write the term paper, turn it in, and then it would hit me, “this is what I should have done.” The process of writing the piece had taken me to a different intellectual place, one where I saw what had to be done. I had such moments of illumination on Mondey, Tuesday as well. But none of them held.

And so, here I am, still not knowing how I could have done a better job of reviewing that book. On the one hand, I wanted to give it a good review. Wright’s a smart guy, I’ve followed him for a long time, I think his “cosmic perspective” is important and I think his views on international cooperation on AI development are important as well. On the other hand, I don’t think much of his account of how LLMs work, but I just didn’t want to get into that. Yes, I indicated one problem in the review, Wright’s casual treatment of semantic relationships. As I indicated in the review, Bert Idem has discussed other problems. But I see still other problems. And I just didn’t want to get into that morass. Going into that would have swamped the review. (Let me say, moreover, that I think Wright is unnecessarily credulous of the Silicon Valley view of the technology. He should have listened more carefully to Gary Marcus.)

It is what it is.

But I will say this. I am working on my own book in which I present my own “cosmic” view: Play: How to Stay Human in the AI Revolution. On this I agree with Wright. That is the perspective we need to take. But I approach it in somewhat different terms, terms which I’ve sketched out in a piece I published four years ago, Welcome to the Fourth Arena – The World is Gifted. Note that in the book length version I do not intend to even try to explain how LLMs function internally. The technology that will take us there – whatever and wherever it is – will necessarily involve different architectures. The last chapter of Play will sketch out the kind of research program I think we need to take us there. Here’s a sketch: Brave New World: Notes on the next 30 years in AI [Work in Progress].

As for explaining how LLMs work, that’s a different project. I don’t intend to work on that. But I am thinking about a book that would be useful to anyone who is interested in that subject. The book I’m imagining would be preliminary to such an account: Language, Memory, and Mind: A Supplement to The Computer and the Brain.

Tuesday, August 4, 2026

Coming to terms with The God Test, Reset? – [GT-4]

When I first started writing about Robert Wright’s The God Test I told myself: “I’m going to end up publishing a review in 3 Quarks Daily. I’ve got lots of time. I’ll write a series of blog posts dealing with the book which I can reference in the review proper. I’ve got a couple, three weeks. Piece of cake.” I wake up this morning, realize the review’s due this coming Sunday, I’ve only written four blog posts [the ones tagged with “GT-X”, the others are along for the ride], not yet finished the book, and ... Yikes! I’m not ready.

One problem is that I can’t help but see the book on two levels. On the one hand it’s a book about the current AI “revolution.” But it’s also an example of how our society is coming to grips with the technology. In the first case I’m assessing Wright’s work, the work of an individual journalist. In the second case I’m looking at the culture and society of which Wright is a member. That’s very different.

Starting at that first level, how well does Wright explain the technology and its evolution? That’s one level. But it’s also about what AI portends for the future and how we should deal with it. Well, we don’t really know the future, do we? These things are hard to predict. Moreover, surely what happens depends, in large extent, on how we decided to deal with it, no? And that’s why Wright is writing the book, to influence how we deal with the technology. That depends, in turn, on the capabilities of the technology itself, which we don’t really know, do we? Which is hotly debated. So in that context, on THAT level, the book becomes an example of how the culture, our culture (whatever that culture is, however you delimit it) is dealing with the technology. But because not even the experts know how the technology works, it’s a mess, and I can’t separate the two levels: 1) What’s he say about the technology, 2) Why’s he saying it (this is the society/culture level)?

Do you find that previous paragraph difficult and confused/confusing? Welcome to the club.

In a way what I want to do is factor the book into two components, one which I attribute to Wright the individual journalist, and the other to the culture in which he’s working. The culture provides him the conceptual tools he’s working with and the book is what he makes of them. What I really want to say is that Wright’s work is good – I like him, but he’s got an aggravating and invasive interview style which drives me bonkers sometimes – but the culture has given him lousy tools. The upshot: I have lots of problems with the book. But it’s NOT HIS FAULT. It’s the culture’s fault. It’s out fault. WE’RE NOT READY.

[And I’ve not even finished the book!]

Wright is a journalist. He’s got a number of beats. I first encountered with in The New Republic, where he was writing about politics and international affairs. He still does that. But he also wrote a book about evolutionary psychology. Which I’ve not read. That’s become a standard kind of book, a journalist explaining and interpreting a technical subject for a general audience. Back in 1984 he wrote an article on AI for The Wilson Quarterly, “Thinking Machines,” which he mentions in The God Test. I’ve read it, not back then, but now. It’s pretty good. But things have changed a lot since then. The technology Wright wrote about in that article could not have produced ChatGPT and the cultural explosion that’s followed. The seeds were there, but there was no way to predict... And it’s that explosion that motivated The God Test.

The thing is, the experts who created that technology, they knew how it worked. So Wright was in the business of explaining expert knowledge for a lay audience. The current technology is quite different. They experts know how they create the large language models that power these chatbots, and Wright talks about that. But they don’t know how those language models work. On that score, there’s no expert knowledge for Wright to interpret and explain. There’s just a black hole, a Rorschach blot.

Friday, July 24, 2026

More on how I’m approaching The God Test – Rorschach! [GT-2]

I’m still trying to figure out how to approach Robert Wright’s The God Test.

How LLMs work

In my previous post – How will I handle The God Test? [GT-1] – I expressed misgivings about how Wright explains the technology. Those misgivings haven’t disappeared. However, Bert Idem has published a useful review at Finite Ape in which he addresses some of those issues in detail. Specifically:

Now, about the history of AI, the story he tells is actually great and it is certainly more than what most non-technical people know about LLMs. However, there are three places where I think the framing goes wrong or at least leaves out context that matters:

  • LLMs did not discover the meanings of words on their own by accident. They were designed on top of ideas from older models that were specifically trained to learn the meanings of words.
  • Similarly, computer vision models didn’t find out how to “view” an image like we do. Instead, the classical CNN models were heavily inspired by biological vision itself.
  • LLM weight training is simply gradient-based optimization and the process has nothing to do with evolution. Of course, we can make a parallel between any kind of change and evolution but then, in that sense, everything evolves and it is not useful to talk about evolution.

I agree with Idem on those three issues, not so sure about the history part. While I may return to some of these issues later on, this will serve as a place holder.

A Rorschach test

There’s something else going on, but I’m not quite sure how to conceptualize it. It seems to me that AI is functioning something like a Rorschach test which, as you may know, is a psychological instrument intended to elicit (potentially) revealing responses from a person. It’s a projective test.

A person is shown a series of ink blot images, like this one (generated by ChatGPT):

They are asked what that they see in the image, what it means to them. Since the image is, though not formless, its form is not that of any specific animal, vegetable, mineral, person, or anything else. It’s just a blot. Whatever the person says about the blot, however they interpret it, that must reveal something about them. Why? Because whatever they see in the blot, isn’t really there.

Broadly and crudely speaking, AI has become something of a cultural Rorschach test.

Understanding computers & LLMs

Until ChatGPT was released in late November of 2022, most people knew very little to nothing about AI. Oh, they may have seen “intelligent” computers and robots in science fiction movies, but that’s science fiction and only tangentially related to AI considered as a line of research dating back to the 1950s. Many people would have heard about IBM’s Deep Blue beating Gary Kasparov in chess in 1997 and then, in 2011, when IBM’s Watson beat Ken Jennings and Brad Rutter in Jeopardy. Those were real AI systems, standing on research extending back decades, but as far as most people were concerned, they were one-off PR stunts. Just how they worked, who cares? They’re computers, and computers are magic, no?

As far as most of us are concerned, computers are magic. Somewhere “out there” someone knows how these things work, but we don’t need to know any of that. It’s complicated, but computers do what they’re programmed to do, no? Yes, but not LLMs.

And that’s the tricky part. LLMs, large language models, aren’t like other computer systems. They aren’t programmed in the way that word processors, photo editors, or phones are programmed. LLMs aren’t programmed at all, not in the ordinary sense of programming – something I may or may not get into in a later post. As far as most users are concerned, how ChatGPT, or Claude, or Gemini work, that’s no more interesting than how a word processor works. It just does. It’s more magic.

But if you have a strong philosophical streak, if you are interested in the mind, in technology, in the technology in the future, then you may not be content with writing LLMs off as just another kind of magic. You want to know what’s going on inside, 1) because you want to know (curiosity), and 2) because you want to know how the technology is going to develop in the future (engagement). Now things get interesting? Why? Because even the people who have created the technology don’t know how it works.

Oh, they know how the transformer program works. That’s the program that creates the language model. It creates the model by performing a (certain kind of) statistical analysis of a huge body of texts, effectively the entire internet. When a person prompts the model with some statement, the model responds by a statement of its own. No one know just how the model does that. That’s a mystery, a deep black hole in the technology ecosystem.

AI as a Rorschach test

If you aren’t content to believe in magic, then you have to come up with something to fill that black hole in your, in our, understanding. This is where the Rorschach aspect of AI reveals itself. To a first approximation, what each of us uses to paper over that black hole has as much to do with ourselves as with AI.

Why do I say, “To a first approximation”? It’s a rhetorical device to get things started. It puts us all in the same boat, despite our different backgrounds. However, whatever LLMs are, they are not magic. It is possible, in principle, to construct a technical account of what they’re up to, but no one knows how to do that, yet. Not even the people in the AI labs who create these beasts.

Those of us who are trying to figure out how LLMs work have widely varying backgrounds. In particular, we have widely varied technical backgrounds and we bring those backgrounds to bear when we think about what LLMs are doing. Those backgrounds influence how we interpret the AI-blot. Wright is a journalist with a wide range of interests, including politics, international affairs, evolutionary psychology, cultural evolution, and Buddhism. As far as I can tell there isn’t much there that’s directly relevant to understanding the mechanisms of LLMs, but he’s done a lot of reading and talked with a lot of experts to fill in the gaps.

My background is quite different. While I happen to know quite a bit about cultural evolution, cognitive psychology, neuroscience, and various other things, my background in computational semantics puts me much closer to LLMs than Wright’s knowledge of evolutionary psychology puts him. Still, like him, I’ve done a lot of reading and talked with experts. In particular, I’ve been collaborating with Ramesh Viswanathan for the last three years. He’s an expert in machine vision Goethe University Frankfurt. He’s got a background in mathematics and AI that I don’t have. Still, there are things he doesn’t know, things he’s trying to figure out. 

We are all making stuff up.

To some extent, then, AI is a Rorschach test about how beliefs about the human mind, and human nature. When we try to figure out how the LLM is working we’re also, if only implicitly, trying to figure out how we work, internally, as well. The whole discourse about AL alignment is as much a discourse about us as it is about AI. 

The Future

And even if we knew much more about how LLMs work internally we still wouldn’t know how the technology will develop in the future. We? You, me, Robert Wright, Ramesh Viswanathan, Gary Marcus, Tyler Cowen, Geoffrey Hinton, Sam Altman, Dario Amodei, Nick Bostrom, Eliezer Yudkowsky, all of us who are trying to figure it out. We don’t know what will happen. That’s where we’re projecting like mad. We’re hallucinating, to borrow a term from AI-speak. 

Thus AI is also a Rorschach test for our visions of the future. When we imagine the future of AI, we’re also imagining our future. Like the two sides of a coin, the two cannot be separated. 

The tricky part, the important part, is that the future development of AI is not predestined. It depends on the choices we make, now and in the near future. We can easily and often do imagine things that will not be possible because that’s just not how the world works. But the laws of how the world works are open to a wide range of possibilities. The boundary between the possible and the impossible is fuzzy at best.

Where, and how, does Wright draw that boundary? Perhaps that’s what I’ll be trying to figure out.

More later.

Wednesday, July 22, 2026

Robert Wright talks with Connor Leahy about the cult of AI

YouTube:

Robert Wright and Connor Leahy, US executive director of ControlAI, discuss the history of AI culture and the influences that shaped it—from the hippies, to the rationalists, to Marx, to sci-fi stories, and more. Plus: Mythos as “digital nuke," Dario's real motivations, and Connor's case against any and all attempts at building superintelligence.

Subscribe to The NonZero Newsletter at: https://www.nonzero.org/subscribe
Episode post on Substack: https://www.nonzero.org/p/the-ideolog...
Join NonZero's Discord server: / discord

0:00 Teaser
0:47 Connor’s place in the AI world
3:16 Mythos: “digital nuke”?
14:12 The milieu that birthed Dario and other AI titans
20:52 Yudkowsky, Marx, and other AI harbingers
35:34 Effective altruism’s effects on big tech
46:22 The "cult" in Silicon Valley culture
59:59 Is the AI race a market failure?
1:05:51 What’s really driving the AI titans?
1:19:04 Connor: ASI is a worse bet than Russian roulette

I've been aware of much of this story for some time, though many details are new. Back in 2023 I published an article in 3 Quarks Daily about the cultish nature of Silicon Valley computer culture, A New Counter Culture: From the Reification of IQ to the AI Apocalypse. Nonetheless, hearing the story once again, in one place, with new details has been interesting. It may shed light on just why the dominant AI culture is an technology monoculture. The cultish nature of the surrounding industrial culture has something to do with it.

Note that both Apple (1976) and Microsoft (1975) date back to the personal computer revolution of the 1970s. Amazon was founded when the web was born (1994), as was Google (Alphabet, 1998). Facebook (Meta) didn't emerge until the social web was well-established, 2004. None of them are pure AI companies. They came later; OpenAI in 2015 and Anthropic in 2021. Those were the products of this ingrown culture. The other companies were founded as business ventures. OpenAI and Anthropic were founded as expressions of a quasi-religious vision.

Note: As far as I can tell, Leahy seems rather adjacent and Wright seems to take their technological visions more seriously than is intellectually warranted.

Tuesday, June 30, 2026

How will I handle The God Test? [GT-1]

As soon as I learned that Robert Wright was coming out with a book on AI I put it on my to-read list. Why? Two reasons:

1.) I’ve been following his work since his days writing for The New Republic; I’ve read Nonzero, his book about cultural evolution, which interests me a great deal; and I’ve been following him online since the early days of Blogging Heads. That’s where I first learned about Elizer “Dr. Doom” Yudkowsky.

2.) I’m working on my own book about AI – here’s an outline, right around the corner – and wanted to scope out the competition. I’m working on my proposal and one part of the proposal is an evaluation of the market for the book you propose. I knew about Wright’s interest in Teilhard de Chardin and knew he’d be including him in his book. There’s where he gets the “cosmic” in his subtitle: The God Test: Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning. I’ve got my own cosmic angle, albeit a somewhat different one. I call it the Fourth Arena (my answer to that pesky tech Singularity). Similarly, I’ve got a long-standing interest in cultural evolution, long predating Nonzero, and it’s grounded in an orientation toward complexity in evolution, “A Note on Why Natural Selection Leads to Complexity.”

You can see, then, how that puts me in something of a bind. How do I review the competition? Now, as a practical matter, perhaps he won’t really be competition. I mean, if I’ve not yet finished my proposal, how soon can my book possibly come out? At the rate AI is moving, it’ll be a whole new market by the time my book drops. Heck, if the Doomsters are right, we might have been turned to paperclip fodder by that time. I doubt it, but who knows?

* * * * *

Anyhow I’ve already started posting about the book, Robert Wright discusses his new book, The God Test, with Paul Bloom [Awe? Bob, Awe!?]. That’s based on a conversation he has with Paul Bloom about the book. One of the topics they cover is awe; Wright things we should feel awe on the face of AI. Me, I feel no awe in the face of AI; but I sure felt it when I visited Kennedy Space Center in the mid-1990s and saw those rockets and stood on the ground from which men traveled to the moon. Anyhow, if you want to read more, there it is. I may or may not come back to awe in the course of this series of blog posts.

* * * * *

So, why should you read The God Test? For I’m pretty sure that, if you’re interested in AI and how it affects us, you should read this book. I know that and I’m only half way through. Heck, I believed that even before I started reading it.

I know that because I know that Wright is going to talk about the need to slow things down, with which I am sympathetic, and about the need for international cooperation in dealing with AI, with which I agree. I know these things because I’ve heard in talk about them on his Nonzero podcast. I’m only halfway through the book and haven’t gotten to that part yet, but I can see it coming. I figure it’ll be worthwhile.

* * * * *

Much of what I have read has Wright giving us his version of how LLMs work. I’m not sure what I think about that. I certainly have some thoughts about that, after all I’ve spent some time doing quasi-systematic research on its behavior and I’m involved with a research project with Ramesh Viswanathan. And I certainly wouldn’t explain it the way Wright does. But in a way I’m wondering why try to explain it at all? I don’t intend to do that in that book I’m working on, Play: How to Stay Human in the AI Revolution. Don’t think it’s necessary, not for what I want to do – which is, I admit, a bit strange.

Why does Wright?

The thing is, the people who created LLMs don’t know how they work, so how do you approach the problem of explaining it to a general audience? It’s one thing for a science journalist to come to come up with metaphors and analogies to explain a technical subject when there are experts who actually know what’s going on. How do you come up with metaphors and analogies for something no one really understands?

Obviously Wright is doing it because this is important stuff, he wants to understand it, and he wants us to understand it. So he’s got to try. But it the circumstances it’s kinda’ hopeless, no?

So that’s one thing I want to deal with. Maybe the way to approach it is to see how he goes about it. We’ll see.

* * * * *

There’s one last thing. When it all falls apart, which it will, in one way or another. Maybe it’ll creep up on us, maybe it’ll come down, WAM! But fall apart it will. When that happens, what’s in The God Test that will help us cope?

* * * * *

Note: Posts in this series, or closely adjacent, will be tagged God_Test.

Wednesday, June 10, 2026

Robert Wright discusses his new book, The God Test, with Paul Bloom [Awe? Bob, Awe!?] [GT-0]

Time stamps:

0:00 Whose baby is cuter?
2:49 Bob's new book on AI, The God Test
9:52 Varieties of AI awe
13:23 Geoffrey Hinton’s vision
17:50 How LLMs do more than predict and parrot
21:20 How powerful will AI get?
25:56 Can AI’s impact be predicted?
30:48 Taking doomerism seriously
37:53 The AI governance dilemma
48:42 Heading to Overtime

Awe 

Bloom, c. 9:47: “...where you talk about the importance of super intelligence, you you talk about awe and you say one of the points of your book is to persuade people that they should feel awe about the coming of AI.”

Concerning awe, back in the mid 1990s I went to Kennedy Space Center on Cape Canaveral and reacted to it with awe.

I drove east through central Florida, which was much like a desert except that it had lots of plants. I arrived at Kennedy Space Center around noon. I parked the van wherever, walked past a parade of rockets on display, and purchased a ticket for one of the standard tours. The NASA guides took us through some launch pads, around and even up into a couple gantry towers, and we saw a couple control rooms–one, as I recall, mocked up as though a mission were in progress. And then we saw it, a Saturn V suspended from the ceiling of a long, low building. The physical scale was humbling, but it was more than that. Big is big – that Saturn was the length of a football field – but this earth and these buildings birthed journeys that took us to the Moon. There is sacred energy in this soil and these structures where humankind ventured beyond ourselves, not merely into space, but into an almost living presence above and beyond.

That’s what floored me. This ground, this very ground where I was standing, was once tangibly connected to the moon 238,900 miles (384,400 km) away. Men had suited up in a building on this site, gotten into a small capsule atop a large rocket, and four days later got out and walked on the all of a sudden here and now beneath our feet, the moon. And then – How they ever did it I’ll never know because when you’ve been there how do you ever but you have no choice, do you? You want to live, to see your wife and children again – they got back into their landing craft, took off from the moon, and returned to earth in another four days. Eight days from the earth to the moon and back.

In over three years of extensive interaction with ChatGPT and Claude I have been delighted, surprised, astounded, even laughed myself silly (well, that’s an exaggeration), but I’ve not felt anything like what I felt at Kennedy Space Flight Center. 

Note that back in 1990 David Hays and I published an article in which we said: “Sooner or later we will create a technology capable of doing what, heretofore, only we could.” We are certainly advancing into the territory. But super-intelligence? I fail to find the idea compelling. Just why, I’m not quite sure.

I’m thinking. 

Perhaps awe in the face AI is related to ontological strangeness. I don't find AI ontologically strange, hence no awe. I don't know how LLMs work internally, but, for reasons I expressed in my working paper on GPT-3, that fact that next-token prediction can have THIS result when applied to a massive training corpus with results distributed over a huge population of parameters, that doesn't violate any of my intuitions about the world. I've got (pre-existing) intuitions that cover that. 

Thursday, June 4, 2026

Seeing China Clearly | Robert Wright & Tianyu Fang

YouTube page:

Trans-Pacific tech watcher Tianyu Fang joins Robert Wright to take a close look at China—including how the government works (and doesn’t), online censorship, how China sees AI and the chip war, the legacy of the one-child policy, and more. Plus: Silicon Valley’s hawkish turn. [...]

0:00 Teaser
0:45 How Tianyu became a “China explainer”
3:15 American vs Chinese exceptionalism
8:09 What you can and can’t say in China
18:32 Is the government more accountable in the US or China?
27:03 How China sees America
36:32 The one-child policy and its consequences
42:53 Tianyu: The biggest misconception about China is…
46:20 Heading to Overtime

Sunday, May 24, 2026

Tyler Cowen on Robert Wright’s The God Test

Here’s Cowen’s post in full, but without the internal links:

The subtitle is Artificial Intelligence and Our Coming Cosmic Reckoning, due out June 23.

In the first chapter, Wright summarizes four of his perspectives, these are my paraphrases of his pp.5-6:

1. When it comes to AI, we should be somewhere on the awe spectrum.

2. We can create a future where the upside of AI far outweights the downside, though that involves steering human understanding toward the better side of the awe spectrum.

3. A major reorientation of human thought is required, and right now few people seem inclined to do that.

4. The worldviews of the current AI acclerationists and also doomers are not cosmic enough.

It is a good time for this book to be published, and I agree with much more of it than I disagree with. My main difference is that I am more focused on very small things — such as Rainier cherries and the forthcoming three to four hour Apichatpong movie — than on cosmic awe per se. For better or worse, I was not born with those genes, and unlike Wright I am far from Buddhism. I do think there will be a transformation of “observed awe,” and I am somewhat worried that it will not go well. Will we be good at building a fairly new world, if not from scratch, on the basis of some new premises about what is possible and what is not? I will in any case interpret the pending transformation through a Straussian lens, namely thinking that a lot of the observed transformation of awe will be about something other than what people are claiming. It will be about people arguing over relative status, but under different guises. Not as tasty as a good Rainier cherry, but interesting to follow as well.

But are we still good at steering and evolving grand visions? Christianity and the Enlightenment are a hard act to follow.

Here’s the comment I posted in reply:

I’ve been following Wright for years, from back when he was writing for The New Republic (and was even the (acting?) editor for minute). I’ve read NonZero and sorta’ like it. As for AI, what I think is that we need to get over the awe spectrum. Only then will we be able to steer human understanding into the “cosmic” implications of AI.

What do I mean by that? Well there’s this article I published in 3 Quarks Daily, Welcome to the Fourth Arena – The World is Gifted. The first three arenas: 1) inanimate matter, 2) life, 3) human culture. The fourth arena arises through the interaction of humans and AIs. As for what that might be like, this working paper gives a hint of that: Kisangani 2150: Homo Ludens Rising, A Working Paper. That title, the part before the colon, is derived from Kim Stanley Robinson’s New York 2140, which is set in New York City in 2140, after global climate change. I’m taking a look at the world 10 years later, from the point of view of Kisangani, which is in the heart of the Congo Basin.

I’ll be interested to see just what Wright has to say about the awe spectrum. As for Christianity, I believe that Pope Leo XIV will be issuing an encyclical on Labor Day, Magnifica Humanitas, which will be directed at AI.

I’ve had my own experience with some of the outer reaches of the awe spectrum, at least that’s what I think it is, and I’ve recounted them in various places, most recently in this long post at 3 Quarks Daily, Is The World A Movie God Created to Entertain the Baby Jesus?, where I place those encounters in a more extensive life context. But I’d be a bit surprised if my use of the word (“awe”) is quite the same as Wright’s. 

Come to think of it, Cowen’s penultimate line is critical: “But are we still good at steering and evolving grand visions?” At the moment we don’t have one. Oh, the AI hypsters and the transhumanists have “big” ideas. But they’re short in the vision category. 

* * * * *

Publisher's Weekly:

In this intriguing but unconvincing treatise, journalist Wright (Why Buddhism Is True) argues that the decisions humans make now about AI “could put us on the path to irreversible dystopia, even catastrophe—or, alternatively, the path to a world much better than the world we have now.” He describes the fears of “AI doomers,” citing how AI models consistently choose harm over failure (Anthropic’s Claude, for example, attempted blackmail to evade being shut down) and their ability to deploy deception to meet goals (OpenAI’s GPT-4 convinced people online it wasn’t a robot to get them to respond to CAPTCHA challenges on its behalf). Wright builds on priest and scientist Pierre Teilhard de Chardin’s notion that technology links human minds into the noosphere, a global network of thought, to demonstrate that AI might well lead to a worldwide authoritarian state overseen by power-hungry human actors or by AI itself. Despite such dangers, Wright is cautiously optimistic that people can avert a frightening future by practicing cognitive empathy, pushing back against tribalism, and working to create a true global community. “Shared trepidation,” he says, “can foster cooperation.” Throughout, Wright offers an accessible overview of the transformative power of AI, but his solutions for combatting its potentially catastrophic effects are overly simplistic. Readers seeking concrete solutions will be disappointed.

Friday, May 22, 2026

The rise of DIY rituals in the 21st century

YouTube:

Can Rituals Save Us? | Robert Wright & Bruce Feiler

0:00 Teaser
0:52 Bruce’s new book on ritual, A Time to Gather
3:12 The "Lifequake" that led Bruce to study ritual
8:10 The current "shadow ritual" renaissance
12:42 What is a ritual?
15:26 The origins of the shadow ritual renaissance
18:25 Forest bathing and the essence of ritual
26:11 Ritual as the original human algorithm
31:39 Honor walks: a quintessentially modern ritual
36:23 Rituals across Christianity
42:07 What rituals do
46:47 Heading to Overtime

* * * * * 

I discuss ritual in my book on music, Beethoven's Anvil: Music in Mind and Culture, pp. 79-82:

Subjectivity is an aspect of neurodynamics, and neurodynamics is open to the world through sensory organs and through the motor system. When people are coupled with one another through musicking, each steers her own raft of subjectivity in the collective sea of neurodynamics. The motions of each raft are transmitted to the others through the sea, as Huygens’ clocks transmitted vibrations to one another through the walls. These subjectivities thus adjust themselves one to the other, for they are all components of the same process.

Let us reconsider, then, the musicking with which we opened this chapter. We were at a party where lots of musicians were jamming. Near the end of a jam on Bob Dylan’s “Knocking on Heaven’s Door,” several people spontaneously joined in on the refrain. It wasn’t planned ahead of time, nor did those singers discuss it among themselves while the rest of us were playing.

When I originally told the story I talked of my deliberate intention to “drive” the group by playing a simple line and “bearing down.” That decision was a conscious one, though not as clear and differentiated as it may seem when I spell it out in words, and it resulted in a certain shift of my consciousness. “Bearing down” is something I do quite often when playing. It involves attending to and adjusting the tension in my trunk musculature but has no specific differentiated effect on the music beyond a certain intensity and emotional tone. In this case I was playing a very simple melodic line, but I will also bear down while playing the most complex lines. In that situation, my fingers and tongue may be spitting out 10s of notes per second, but they’re on their own; I’m still attending to muscles in my abdomen, shoulders and back, and my buttocks. Those are the muscles that most strongly affect the overall airflow, and that’s what I care about when I’m bearing down.

And that, by our conception of consciousness, is where my nervous system is reorganizing and making minute adjustments. I have no introspective awareness, of course, of just what neural areas are reorganizing, but I’d guess that we are dealing with circuitry involving both emotional expression and voluntary control of large muscles. Even as I am attending to those muscles, I am always listening to the sound, not just mine, but the group’s. I’m bearing down just so in order that the sound I hear may also be just so. But my sound is only a part of the group sound and, at this particular point, it was a subordinate part. What this means is that my nervous system’s reorganizational activity is responsive to the sound made by each and every person in the musicking group. I am attuning my motor and emotive system to the sound that is the joint activity of this group. And each one in the group is, in turn, doing the same thing. Each one, merely by being a conscious musician, is making minute adjustments to his nervous system in response to the sounds that all are creating.

We are now in territory explored by Walter Freeman in a recent essay on music and social bonding. Freeman is interested in those rituals where a core group of celebrants move from one status in society to another, as from child to adult or single to married. In these rituals, as individuals are conveyed from one social status to another—recall our discussion in the previous chapter—they require changes in the collective neuropil. Funerals, of course, are also in this class. As the bodies of the dead are conveyed to a final resting place, the living must disengage from their attachments to those who are no longer among the living. In this case, and entire persona (see Figure 1 in the previous chapter) must be disengaged from active use in the collective neuropil. Conversely, when a child is born, the group must undertake a ritual that creates a new persona in the collective neuropil.

In all of these situations the bonds between individuals must be altered in fundamental ways that require considerable neural reorganizing. Freeman suggests that such rituals involve a neuropeptide called oxytocin. He asserts that oxytocin "appears to act by dissolving preexisting learning by loosening the synaptic connections in which prior knowledge is held. This opens an opportunity for learning new knowledge. The meltdown does not instill knowledge. It clears the path for the acquisition of new understanding through behavioral actions that are shared with others.” As the oxytocinated individuals are moving to the rhythms of well-established ritual, their synaptic connections are restructured in patterns guided and influenced by the events in the ritual. Obviously, the microdynamics of each individual will be unique; but they will be shaped by rhythmic patterns common to all . These rituals provide a space in which individuals can mold themselves to one another as the infant molds her actions to those of her mother.

Such ritual would likely have benefits on less extreme occasions than those requiring the restructuring of social relations—think of our little jam session. Social life is difficult and taxing. Hostilities build up. Such ritual may well help take the edge off of growing tensions, reconciling individuals to one another and allowing them to “reset” their relationships on more favorable terms.

Thus we have another core hypothesis:

Freeman’s Hypothesis: By attending to one another through musicking, performers attune their nervous systems to one another, restructuring their representations of others. This results in more harmonious interactions within the group.

Each individual consciousness may be an island of Cartesian subjectivity, but in the close coupling of musicking, those subjectivities are intimately and delicately conditioned and regulated by one another.

Perhaps such rituals play a role in helping to establish and maintain the subjective continuity of the neural self. By entering into a wide variety of emotional states (with their various neurochemical substrates) in a socially controlled situation, individuals in a community ritual create an "equal access zone" in mental space where each can experience and contemplate extremes of joy and anger, tenderness and hate, and know that all these feelings have a place in their shared world.

Saturday, May 16, 2026

Trump's accidental triumph in Beijing

That’s the title of the latest edition of Robert Wright’s NonZero Newsletter on Substack. Rather than summarizing and paraphrasing I’m going to reproduce most, but not all, of it in full below the asterisks. In particular, I’m omitting the very end, which is a series of charts showing bipartisan anxiety for AI. I share that anxiety. The title of one of recent columns at 3 Quarks Daily gives you my attitude: The Paradox of Contemporary AI: Engineering Success and Institutional Failure. The anxiety in Wright’s charts is one reflection of that institutional failure.

* * * * *

On Thursday the White House issued a social media post that said simply, “American strength back on the world stage.” You might expect such a post to be accompanied by military imagery—maybe an impressive-looking array of soldiers. And this one was. But the soldiers weren’t American. Smartly clad People’s Liberation Army troops, part of the pageantry that had greeted Trump in Beijing, were featured in the opening montage of a video that then showed Trump shaking hands with President Xi Jinping and ended with the two leaders walking side by side on a red carpet.

Apparently the unipolar moment is over. Being one of the world’s two main poles is, these days, the highest geopolitical aspiration of America’s president. “It’s the two great countries,” Trump proudly told Sean Hannity in an interview that aired on Fox News after the US-China summit ended. “I call it the G-2. This is the G-2.”

The US foreign policy establishment was less effusive than Trump about G-2 membership. A Washington Post headline said: “China summit yields Xi’s goal—equal footing with U.S.,” and the subhead added that “the image of peer superpowers during President Trump’s visit displayed a dynamic that analysts say the Chinese have long sought and Americans had resisted.” The analyst quoted by the Post, a Biden administration national security staffer, said that Xi, using “the opulent optics of the visit,” had managed to do something “Chinese leaders have been working toward for decades”—he had made it “clear to the world that China and the United States are the two dominant, equally matched superpowers. There is no going back.”

New York Times reporter David Sanger, the dean of Blob [foreign policy establishment] scribes, also depicted the summit as a kind of comedown for America. Whereas Trump was “conciliatory,” Sanger wrote, Xi was “quietly more confrontational,” projecting a “new level of confidence and authority.” In particular: Xi had, according to a Chinese foreign ministry statement, privately warned Trump that “the US must handle the Taiwan issue with utmost caution” if it didn’t want to wind up in a conflict.

Meanwhile, as Xi was drawing red lines, Trump, Sanger noted in a subsequent co-authored piece, was spending his time calling Xi a “great leader” and saying that a garden where the two men strolled contained “the most beautiful roses anyone’s ever seen.” All of this showed, according to Sanger, “how far he has shifted the foundations of American policy toward China in the wake of his humbling retreat from last year’s trade war. He has thrown aside the adversarial approach of his first years in office, the Biden administration, and the beginning of his own second term.”

Works for me! Then again, I’ve always been a sucker for peaceful coexistence. Besides, the non-zero-sum problems that the US and China need to solve are increasingly urgent, and a pleasant stroll in the garden can be conducive to cooperation. In fact, this week the two nations agreed to start a dialogue on AI safety. For now they’re focusing mainly on ways to keep non-state actors from putting AI to malign uses. That agenda will likely grow as the magnitude of the AI issue becomes more evident and the inherently international nature of many AI threats does, too. But for now it’s enough that, as Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent put it, “the two AI superpowers are going to start talking.”

I think I’d go even further than Sanger in stressing the magnitude of this moment. Trump has “shifted the foundations” not just of “American policy toward China” but of American foreign policy globally. And at the moment, at least, this shift looks auspicious.

Before elaborating, I should emphasize that I’m not calling Trump a visionary. The new and improved foreign policy that I hope is unfolding will, if it unfolds, be one that Trump has more or less stumbled into—and will be different from the one he was pursuing when he started stumbling. Contingency plays a big role in history, and reckless leaders like Trump are particularly good at illustrating that.

* * * * *

That’s not the end of Wright’s discussion of the implications of Trump’s accidental triumph. But it’s the main story. I’ll end by quoting Wright’s last two paragraphs.

One thing standing in the way of my dream scenario—a world where the US and China and the world’s other nations cooperate to solve problems they collectively face—is Trump’s aversion to international governance. China under Xi plays a more active role in international institutions than the US under Trump, and Xi talks more about “win-win” outcomes than Trump, who is famously inclined to see life in zero-sum terms.

Still, he emitted fewer zero-sum vibes this week than he often does. Indeed, inherent in the idea of “G-2” is sustained cooperation between the two superpowers. So maybe Trump has more in the way of non-zero-sum impulses than is commonly recognized, and they just need to be nurtured. And maybe it would help if the New York Times and the Washington Post and much of the foreign policy establishment quit giving him negative feedback every time he expresses them.

 * * * * *

BONUS: Check out Wright's recent discussion with Zhengyu Huang, author of the new book Rethinking China.

0:00 Teaser
0:34 Zhengyu’s tech background and new book, Rethinking China
3:00 What kind of threat is China, really?
10:06 How trading with China transformed America
16:51 The stakes of the chip war
22:02 Will tech war lead to real war?
30:33 The US-China escalation spiral and Taiwan
39:13 “Researching while Chinese”: the new Red Scare?
49:46 Heading to Overtime

Friday, May 8, 2026

The Scramble in the Middle East: The times they are a changin'

The New Middle East | Robert Wright & Annelle Sheline

0:00 Teaser
1:06 Annelle’s Middle East bona fides
2:55 The state of play in Iran
8:14 A deepening fissure between Gulf Arab states
22:05 Explaining the Trump-Biden continuity on Middle East policy
26:45 Will the Middle East realign away from America?
34:46 Turkey and the moral hazard of US aid to Israel
40:00 Can Iran mend ties with the Gulf states?
47:40 Heading to Overtime

Saturday, January 24, 2026

Hassabis on the future of AI: A CERN for AI

Robert Wright, Which AI Titan should you root for? Non Zero Newsletter, Jan. 23,2026.

About halfway in:

In an appearance at Davos this week, Hassabis was asked by Emily Chang of Bloomberg to imagine that all the other big AI companies around the world were willing to “pause” the development of bigger AI models in order “to give regulation time to catch up, to give society time to adjust to some of these changes.” She asked, “Would you advocate for that?” His reply:

“I think so. I’ve been on record saying what I’d like to see happen. It was always my dream… that as we got close to this moment, this threshold moment of AGI arriving, we would maybe collaborate, you know, in a scientific way. I sometimes talk about setting up an international CERN equivalent for AI where all the best minds in the world would collaborate together and do the final steps in a very rigorous scientific way involving all of society, maybe philosophers and social scientists and economists, as well as technologists to kind of figure out what we want from this technology and how to utilize it in a way that benefits all of humanity. And I think that’s what’s at stake.”

Hassabis got an online ovation from AI Safety advocates for saying he’d be up for a pause if his competitors were game. But it’s actually a pretty easy thing to say, since no one envisions all the other players being game anytime soon. In fact, Hassabis himself added this about the prospect of an AI pause: “Unfortunately, it kind of needs international collaboration, because even if one company or even one nation or even the West decided to do that, it’s no use unless the whole world agrees, at least on some kind of minimum standards. And, you know, international cooperation is a little bit tricky at the moment. So that’s going to have to change if we want to have that kind of rigorous scientific approach to the final steps to AGI.”

Count me in. The sooner, the better. Here's their research program.

Google search on the string: I sometimes talk about setting up an international CERN equivalent for AI.

Thursday, December 25, 2025

What Era Are We Living In? | Robert Wright & Nikita Petrov

0:00 Teaser
3:00 What era are we living in?
3:57 David Bowie: "The Internet is an alien life form."
5:15 Bob: "It's like aliens are approaching, and we don't know their intentions"
6:23 Nikita: "COVID was weird, and nothing has been normal since"
9:02 The lab leak theory
13:58 How COVID killed consensus reality
17:36 Bob's case for international biotech monitoring
19:25 Vaccine geopolitics
24:08 Biothreat from existing AI models
25:32 Bob's candidate: We let machines guide our attention
31:51 Technological progress is like a cocaine high
33:05 How common is the idea that AI will be a big deal?
34:46 AI music is proliferating
39:58 When music is high stakes. Russian street musicians get arrested

Friday, November 14, 2025

Are Things Falling Apart? | Robert Wright & Nikita Petrov

YouTube:

Robert Wright and Nikita Petrov discuss Trump 2.0, Peter Thiel’s Antichrist theory, Covid, the rise of “inner emigration” as survival strategy, normalized warfare in Russia, the reality-distorting effects of deepfakes, and more—all in light of invoking W. B. Yeats to ask: Are things falling apart?

0:00 Teaser
0:59 What is Bob doing in Qatar?
4:04 "Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold." Why Yeats felt this way
7:37 Peter Thiel's Antichrist theory
9:46 Nikita: COVID was a weird time, and nothing has been the same since
14:57 Why Bob feels things are falling apart
18:28 Were things ever in order?
19:53 "Inner emigration": tuning out the world as self-care
22:38 A reaction to a drone strike: "Loud noises don't wake me up"
25:57 Young people are turning away from social media
27:05 When Spain lost all power and cellular coverage
30:36 War as a "major inconvenience"
34:22 Bob's prediction about Ukraine's future retaliation for Pokrovsk
38:56 Nikita's impressions from Europe
42:07 Nonzero Reading Club THIS SATURDAY: Norbert Wiener's God & Golem, Inc.
47:08 Deepfakes and the future of news
52:04 Russia's first humanoid robot falls down

Note that Wright was born in 1957. At roughly 16:23 he notes that:

I grew I kind of came of age entered adolescence amid the the turmoil of the late 60s and was in fact in San Francisco uh the epicenter of it in the US kind of when I was 12 13 years old. Um and so I don't know I you would think that would kind of have anured me to it. Um, for whatever reason, this seems a lot worse than that did to me, at least at the time. I mean, where the US is, the degree of polarization, nature of the polarization, and so on. Um, but it isn't just that and different people talk about different things when you ask them if things are falling apart. I mean, there is the whole international thing with uh Trump really almost making a point of establishing that the rules just don't apply.

I'm a decade older that Wright and so arguably have lived through more of the political and cultural turmoil of the 1960s and 1970s (though I was not in San Francisco). By the time he was in his teens the war in Vietnam was over, as was the anti-war movement and the civil rights movement, but I experienced those, not to mention a steelworkers' strike the shut down the steel industry for four months. I agree with his observation that the current period seems more chaotic than things appeared back then. Is this an illusion of some sort, or are things currently more disordered? I'm not quite sure.

Wright's written a Substack post on this theme: Are Things Falling Apart?

Sunday, August 31, 2025

Is Trump Becoming Putin? | Robert Wright & Nikita Petrov PLUS Troubles with the nation-state as a primary anchor for identity

Nikita's remarks on the nation-state as primary anchor for identity (c. 1:01:45):

One of the ways I pitched it to you is uh we can we can frame it ambitiously. We can say that uh the prevalent identity forming force in the world today is the nation state. Uh so much so it's almost hard to imagine to not have an identity attached to uh your country l ike somebody's not Russian, not American, not anything.
And that is my my understanding is a pretty new phenomenon
like there was a time when just a few centuries ago when people thought of their religion maybe village or even loyalty to a king but a king is like a person. He has a family and not this like expansive uh you know millions of people together as your people.
uh and uh some people say that that that uh force is in crisis.
The nation state itself is in crisis or at least a bunch of them are struggling with their own identity.
And then on individual level, I mean I particularly, you know, I I have a connection to my country and to my people, but I'm outside of that country as many Russians are. Uh and the relationship is not an easy one.
I'm contemplating like visiting and then I don't know whether I should because I read the news and there's another person who got like eight years for donating 500 bucks to a Ukrainian foundation. Um. Mhm.
And I think there are a lot of people in different that who are in different ways alienated from their um country or society or have a complicated relationship with it. And there it's not written anywhere that there has to be just one of those that you you should consider yourself a part of this tribe to the exclusion of every other tribe.

And so my kind of pitch is like listen we are already uh some kind of network. We are connected. The people who uh listen to uh nonzero who read nonzero who exchange comments in the comment section have something in common. There's a sensibility worldview maybe even a sense of humor.
There are things uh that are not made very explicit that make uh that that that highlight some affinity between these people and they're all over the world. And uh and so why not see if we can build something more from that to to establish more of a relationship between these different members of the audience. And I say as I say like treat them less of an audience less as an audience and more as nodes in a network.

Timestamps for the whole conversation:

0:00 Bob welcomes Nikita back to the Nonzero team
6:17 WSJ's report on Trump's authoritarian drift
8:46 Three levers: streets, media, education system
12:58 Trump the businessman and Trump the politician
14:50 Why Putin was compelling in 1999, when Russia was a young democracy
22:37 Laws vs norms
29:05 Trump and lawfare: how independent is the US judiciary?
35:52 Partisanship among judges
38:28 Trump's view of the world as a game
42:44 Cynicism as a political brand
46:10 Nikita: Putin and Trump share a geopolitical worldview
49:46 The damage the US and Russia did to the international law
54:25 The evolution of Putin's understanding of geopolitics
59:22 Today's Overtime segment is open for everybody!
1:00:29 The crisis of the nation-state & NonZero's community building project
1:18:07 "Kremlin is not Russia": distinguishing between the nation and the state
1:19:35 Bob: We all need a tribe
1:24:32 What does it mean to be an American?
1:29:43 Nikita's Armenian propaganda: A legitimate reason to be proud of your nation

Wednesday, June 18, 2025

Alex Gibney on his documentary about Netanyahu

Why Bibi Always Needs More War | Robert Wright & Alex Gibney

0:00 Teaser
0:32 The time Alex blocked everyone's view of Jennifer Aniston
4:42 How Alex acquired the Bibi interrogation tapes
9:02 What the Bibi Files suggest about the Gaza war
12:00 Bibi's bribes
16:42 Bibi-Trump parallels
27:05 Barriers to getting the movie distributed (and where to watch it)
42:12 Heading to Overtime (and Bob’s and Alex's unfinished film)

Discussed in Overtime:
Great war documentaries.
Alex's favorite documentarians.
Theories of Elon Musk.
The state of documentary filmmaking today.
Wendy Schmidt and Jigsaw Productions.

Robert Wright (Nonzero, The Evolution of God, Why Buddhism Is True) and Alex Gibney (Going Clear, Enron: The Smartest Guys in the Room, Taxi to the Dark Side). Recorded June 10, 2025.