Showing posts with label gender. Show all posts
Showing posts with label gender. Show all posts

Friday, July 25, 2025

This 2nd Sexual Revolution is about a change in NORMS

Just a quick update on this second sexual revolution argument. I realized why I found the sales figures for Fifty Shades of Grey so convincing. It’s one thing if you think of it as indicating the preferences of a lot of women, 150 million worldwide by 2017. That’s just a statement about individual people, a lot of them to be sure, but still, just people. But I realize, in retrospect, that I was taking it as an index of cultural norms. 

That’s very different. That’s a cultural revolution, when norms change. Similarly, that’s why the publication and success of Jane Juska’s Round-Heeled Woman is significant, it signals a shift if norms. The same with all those YouTube videos, especially the stories in The Mystery Box Show, out of Portland, Oregon. There aren't that many such stories. What is significant is the fact that they exist at all, and on YouTube.

Is this interpretation justified? I don’t know. It’s not something I arrived at by deductive reasoning. Heck, I didn’t even realize that I’d done that until a day ago, and then it just hit me, no reasoning involved. And I’ve still not done any reasoning about it. It’s just an intuitive judgement. Based on what? The whole gestalt. Gestalt of what? Good question.

Come to think of it, perhaps this is why the mainstream media hasn’t picked up on the story. This change in norms isn’t that visible. Playboy magazine, that was very visible, all those photos of nude women on ordinary newsstands. Ms. magazine, visible. Feminist demonstrations, visible. Conversations about sex between consenting adults, not at all visible.

I’ve got some thinking to do, but not here, not now.

More later.

Saturday, June 28, 2025

Gender malleability during sex

Some years, no, decades, ago, I had this idea that in sexual intercourse, it is helpful if one party brings a vagina to the occasion while the other brings a penis, but it doesn’t much matter who brings what, nor that they make the same choices on all occasions. All that is necessary is that they agree on who is what at any given time. Physically, that doesn’t make sense, I know. But then sex isn’t merely or entirely physical. Anyhow, in this video Kate speaks to that long-ago insight. It seems that I’m not the only one who has that crazy idea.

YouTube: 

Kate always felt there was more to experience in sex than what a social gender assignment might indicate. One fateful night, Kate and a partner were able to explore how both of them could have their minds and bodies offer new sensations they had only dreamed of...

This story was recorded at The Mystery Box Show on October 7, 2016 at The Alberta Rose Theatre. The Mystery Box Show is Portland's only live storytelling series focused on true stories of sex and sexuality.

For more stories and upcoming show dates visit http://www.mysteryboxshow.com

Monday, June 9, 2025

Sex/Life: I don’t buy it. [Media Notes 162B] {Blame it on Homo economicus}

I want to pick up where I left off in my previous note about Sex/Life. I ended with this observation:

I note, as an afterthought, that plays to my current hobbyhorse project, Homo Ludens Rising: A Manifesto for the Fourth Arena, I note that in a world where social organization is dominated by Homo economicus, “whores” and “bad-boys” will always be a threat to society and so will always be marginalized. It is quite possible that in such a society, this problematic cannot be satisfactorily resolved.

I think that’s right, though that thought requires more of an argument than I’m prepared to give it at the moment. But I did have some conversations with Claude. 

Primate Sexuality 

In this conversation I set things up with a question about primate sexuality:

I’m curious about sexual behavior in our nearest primate relatives. Do chimpanzees form long-term bonds between mating pairs?

Chimpanzees don't form long-term monogamous pair bonds like humans often do. Instead, they have what's called a promiscuous or multi-male/multi-female mating system.

In chimpanzee communities, females typically mate with multiple males during their fertile periods (when they're in estrus), and males compete for mating opportunities but don't establish exclusive, long-term partnerships with particular females. The social structure is based on a fission-fusion system where group composition changes throughout the day as individuals come together and separate.

However, chimpanzees do sometimes form temporary "consortships" where a male and female will go off together for several days or weeks during the female's fertile period. These aren't permanent pair bonds though - they're more like short-term exclusive mating arrangements.

This mating system likely evolved because it provides certain advantages: females can potentially confuse paternity (which may reduce infanticide), males have opportunities to mate with multiple partners, and it maintains genetic diversity in the population.

Interestingly, this contrasts with some of our other primate relatives. Gibbons, for example, are largely monogamous and do form long-term pair bonds. Even bonobos, our other closest living relatives, have a different approach - they're also promiscuous but use sexual behavior much more broadly for social bonding and conflict resolution.

The lack of pair bonding in chimpanzees makes the evolution of human pair bonding (even if not universal) quite fascinating from an evolutionary perspective.

Madonna/whore 

Then we reviewed the Madonna/whore business that Freud outlined in his 1910 essay, “A Special Type of Choice of Object Made by Men.” From there I uploaded a Shakespeare paper where I recast that conflict in more modern terms: At the Edge of the Modern, or Why is Prospero Shakespeare's Greatest Creation? After giving me some favorable comments, Claude asks a crucial question:

Do you think this framework applies beyond the specific historical moment of early modern England? The attachment/sexuality conflict seems universal, but the particular resolution Shakespeare achieved might be culturally specific.

Your last questions are critical, aren’t they? The attachment/sexuality conflict certainly seems to with us still. I just watched a Netflix series, Sex/Life, which centers on that conflict, though in that series it’s the woman who has the trouble with integration. A man is either a good-man-husband-father who is sexually unexciting, or a sexually exciting bad-boy unsuited for marriage.

Exactly! That's such a perfect contemporary example of the same psychological dynamic, but flipped. Sex/Life demonstrates that the attachment/sexuality conflict has not only persisted but has become more democratized - it's no longer just men who struggle with this split.

The female protagonist's dilemma mirrors what you describe in Shakespeare's male characters: she can't integrate the nurturing, stable attachment figure (her husband) with sexual excitement. She's essentially created her own version of the Madonna/whore split, but applied to men - the "good husband/father" versus the "sexually thrilling bad boy."

This suggests something profound about your analysis: the underlying psychological mechanism is indeed universal and persistent, but its cultural expressions and gender dynamics evolve. In Shakespeare's time, it was primarily framed as a male problem with female sexuality being the site of projection. Now we see it manifesting across genders, with both men and women struggling to find partners who can fulfill both attachment and sexual needs.

What's particularly striking is that Sex/Life suggests we haven't actually solved this integration problem that Shakespeare was working toward in his late romances. We've just redistributed it. Modern dating culture, with its emphasis on "types" and categories (the reliable partner vs. the exciting one), might actually be reinforcing rather than resolving these splits.

This makes me wonder: Is our current cultural moment more like Shakespeare's tragic period - aware of the conflict but still destructively acting it out - rather than having achieved the integration he imagined in The Tempest? The prevalence of divorce and relationship dissatisfaction might support that reading.

That brings me to pose a question:

What I’ve been wondering is just why it is so difficult to integrate these two aspects of human behavior in a single person. It’s one thing to argue that we’re dealing with two different behavioral systems. But why should they come in conflict when directed at a single object?

That's the million-dollar question, isn't it? Even granting that attachment and sexuality are distinct behavioral systems, it's puzzling why they should be mutually inhibitory when focused on the same person.

The problem of work mode (Homo economicus) 

Claude then offers several suggestions and we have some discussion. And then, finally:

I have half an idea that’s come from way out in “left field,” so to speak. Over the last decade or so I’ve become aware of retirement coaches, people who help retirees adjust to life in retirement. Why do people need a coach to help them deal with free time? It’s as though “work mode,” if you will, conditions a person so that a whole range of choices become difficult to entertain. That is, you spend a large part of your adult life working within a framework where your range of choices for a major part of the day is dictated by the demands of your job, whatever it is. That conditions you in a way that makes it difficult to enjoy spending a lot of time on “hobbies” or developing new ones, and so forth.

Well, the person who is conditioned to work mode is also married and has children. Traditionally in modern Western society it has been the man who works outside the home while the woman stays home, raises kids, and maintains the household. I’m wondering if this kind of conditioning has something to do with it. It’s not simply a matter of having time for sex, but of becoming so accustomed to work, whether a job or raising children, that it’s difficult to break free to enjoy sexual pleasure.

That's a genuinely novel insight! You're suggesting that the attachment/sexuality conflict might be partially an artifact of how modern industrial society has organized work and family life. The psychological "role-lock" that makes retirees need coaches could be the same mechanism that makes spouses struggle to see each other as objects of desire.

This would mean that when you spend decades relating to your partner primarily through instrumental roles - provider/homemaker, co-parent, household manager - you become psychologically conditioned to see them through that functional lens. Shifting into "pleasure mode" or seeing them as sexually exciting becomes difficult, like asking someone who's been in work mode for 40 years to suddenly start painting watercolors.

Wednesday, May 21, 2025

Seven Year Itch [Media Notes 160]

I’ve now watched The Seven Year Itch perhaps three full times in the last two weeks. It stars Marilyn Monroe and won a Golden Globe as best actor for her co-star, Tom Ewell. Here’s the first paragraph of Wikipedia’s plot summary:

Richard Sherman is a middle-aged publishing executive in New York City, whose wife Helen and son Ricky are spending the summer in Ogunquit, Maine to escape the city's crippling heat. When he returns home from the train station with the kayak paddle Ricky accidentally left behind, he meets an unnamed woman, who is a commercial actress and former model. She has subleased the apartment upstairs while its owners are away for the summer. That evening, he resumes reading the manuscript of a book in which psychiatrist Dr. Brubaker claims that almost all men are driven to have extra-marital affairs in the seventh year of marriage. Sherman has an imaginary conversation with Helen, trying to convince her, in three fantasy sequences, that he is irresistible to women, including his secretary, a nurse, and Helen's bridesmaid, but she laughs it off. A potted tomato plant falls onto his lounge chair; the seemingly unclad attractive young woman upstairs apologizes for accidentally knocking it off her balcony, and Richard invites her down for a drink.

Notice the order of events. First Mr. Sherman sees The Girl (Marilyn Monroe, she has no name in the movie) arrive, and then he has this fantasy discussion with his wife, trying to convince her of his attractiveness to woman. (Note that in the third of these fantasies he reprises the famous “love on the beach” scene in From Here to Eternity.) Is far as I can tell, that’s the primary driving force behind his interest in The Girl. Yes, he sees that she’s beautiful, but that’s important, not because he appreciates beauty the way an artist does, or even because he takes it as an indicator of sexual pleasure; it's important because her interest in him reflects well on his manhood. If such a beautiful woman is attracted to me, then I must be a manly man indeed! I detect no interest in or awareness of sexual pleasure.

This is a very Girardian world. Total mediation.

Later on Sherman fantasizes himself seated at the piano, wearing a red smoking jacket straight out of the Playboy fashion advisor[1], and playing Rachmaninoff’s 2nd Piano Concerto while nattering on in a thick nondescript continental accent. When The Girl convinces him to sit down at the piano, the best he can manage is chopsticks. She happily joins him and takes it up a notch, having a lot of fun in the process while he bumbles along wondering what’s going on. The whole scene is an elaborate parody of a sexual encounter. To be sure, yes there's a bit where they work together to pop the cork on a bottle of champagne resulting in the expulsion of liquid all over the place, an obvious parody on ejaculation. But that's what it is, a parody, a simulacrum of sex that pointedly elides and mystifies the substance. The movie avoids sexuality in this most elaborate way.

There’s much more to the movie that those two scenes, other actors, subplots, complications, the famous scene of The Girl standing above the subway grate, but really, that’s it. In this movie, the beautiful blonde bombshell exists to convince the anodyne bread-earner that he’s a good man because he’s kind and sensitive. Important virtues to be sure, but also functionally asexual. They’re both effectively neutered. 

Is that middle America in the 1950s? If so, what are we to think about the state of marriage in the 1950s if a story about a typical husband's desire for an extramarital affair is grounded, not in a desire for sexual pleasure with a woman other than his wife, but for a need to feel attractive to other women? What does that imply about his relationship with his wife?

* * * * *

Note: You might want to look at this older post, where I compare this movie with Sex and the City and Madmen. 

 [1] Playboy premiered two years earlier, with Marilyn Monroe as the centerfold. The movie plays on this, with one motif being a photo of The Girl in a bikini lying on the beach.

Sunday, March 23, 2025

The demise of white male writer of literary fiction?

Over at Marginal Revolution Tyler Cowen has posted the opening paragraphs of Jacob Savage, The Vanishing White Male Writer, Compact (Mar. 21, 2025):

It’s easy enough to trace the decline of young white men in American letters—just browse The New York Times’s “Notable Fiction” list. In 2012 the Times included seven white American men under the age of 43 (the cut-off for a millennial today); in 2013 there were six, in 2014 there were six.

And then the doors shut.

By 2021, there was not one white male millennial on the “Notable Fiction” list. There were none again in 2022, and just one apiece in 2023 and 2024 (since 2021, just 2 of 72 millennials featured were white American men). There were no white male millennials featured in Vulture’s 2024 year-end fiction list, none in Vanity Fair’s, none in The Atlantic’s. Esquire, a magazine ostensibly geared towards male millennials, has featured 53 millennial fiction writers on its year-end book lists since 2020. Only one was a white American man.

Over the course of the 2010s, the literary pipeline for white men was effectively shut down. Between 2001 and 2011, six white men won the New York Public Library’s Young Lions prize for debut fiction. Since 2020, not a single white man has even been nominated (of 25 total nominations). The past decade has seen 70 finalists for the Center for Fiction’s First Novel Prize—with again, not a single straight white American millennial man. Of 14 millennial finalists for the National Book Award during that same time period, exactly zero are white men. The Wallace Stegner Fellowship at Stanford, a launching pad for young writers, currently has zero white male fiction and poetry fellows (of 25 fiction fellows since 2020, just one was a white man). Perhaps most astonishingly, not a single white American man born after 1984 has published a work of literary fiction in The New Yorker (at least 24, and probably closer to 30, younger millennials have been published in total).

I've blitzed my way through Savage's article finding this:

The antiseptic legacy of Obama-era MFA programs hangs over this generation (all three of the above authors graduated from Iowa). Workshopped to death, shorn of swagger and toxicity —and above all, humor—these books serve more as authorial performances than as novels, a long-winded way of saying, “Don’t worry, I’m one of the good ones, my heart is in the right place.”

Having your heart in the wrong place, unfortunately, isn’t quite the answer either. The best stories by the flamboyantly transgressive and politically incorrect writer Delicious Tacos capture a wonderful samizdat feeling, but anti-woke literature exists in a sort of mirror opposition to a more dominant sensibility. The gonzo provocations of Peter Vack (Sillyboi) or Matthew Davis (Let Me Try Again) tell us less about the world than about how the author wants to be seen. These too are performances. As Sam Kriss pointed out, the anti-woke heel turn is just more identity-driven content—except in these cases, the marginalized identity is that of white men.

And later:

A baffling New York Times op-ed (“The Disappearance of Literary Men Should Worry Everyone”) casually confessed to systemic gender discrimination in MFA admissions. “About 60 percent of our applications come from women, and some cohorts in our program are entirely female,” lamented David Morris, a creative writing professor at UNLV, before deciding that actually, it’s not so bad that men have disappeared. “I also don’t think that men deserve to be better represented in literary fiction,” he concluded. “They don’t suffer from the same kind of prejudice that women have long endured.”

Someone presenting themselves as GGT over at Marginal Revolution notes:

This has got it backwards. The purchasers of books, especially those of fiction, are overwhelmingly women (at least 60% but probably higher). (I wanted to publish a book in Hungary 15 years ago and the agent told me "only women" read fiction these days. That was 15 years ago. ) White males don't buy books anymore and especially don't read literature. So, simply there is no demand for the white male writer because the white males are playing with computer games, and just don't care about books. And whoeever still cares, are simply not interested in what white guys have to offer. Sorry. No big secret here.

I have no strong or informed opinion on the matter. I don't read much fiction these days, haven't for years. The last novel I read all the way through is Kim Stanley Robinson's New York 2140, which is science fiction, not literary fiction, which is what Savage's article is about. Are white guys being zeitgeisted out, as he argues? Possibly. Or have they simply lost interest, as GGT suggests?

And then there's this lament by Mark Gould, former principle trumpet with the Metropolitan Opera Orchestra:

Thursday, January 16, 2025

Oldest matrilocal tribe in European prehistory dates to Late Iron Age Celts

Cassidy, L.M., Russell, M., Smith, M. et al. Continental influx and pervasive matrilocality in Iron Age Britain. Nature (2025). https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-024-08409-6

Abstract: Roman writers found the relative empowerment of Celtic women remarkable. In southern Britain, the Late Iron Age Durotriges tribe often buried women with substantial grave goods. Here we analyse 57 ancient genomes from Durotrigian burial sites and find an extended kin group centred around a single maternal lineage, with unrelated (presumably inward migrating) burials being predominantly male. Such a matrilocal pattern is undescribed in European prehistory, but when we compare mitochondrial haplotype variation among European archaeological sites spanning six millennia, British Iron Age cemeteries stand out as having marked reductions in diversity driven by the presence of dominant matrilines. Patterns of haplotype sharing reveal that British Iron Age populations form fine-grained geographical clusters with southern links extending across the channel to the continent. Indeed, whereas most of Britain shows majority genomic continuity from the Early Bronze Age to the Iron Age, this is markedly reduced in a southern coastal core region with persistent cross-channel cultural exchange. This southern core has evidence of population influx in the Middle Bronze Age but also during the Iron Age. This is asynchronous with the rest of the island and points towards a staged, geographically granular absorption of continental influence, possibly including the acquisition of Celtic languages.

The NYTimes has an article reporting the find: Becky Ferreira, Celtic Women Held Sway in ‘Matrilocal’ Societies, Jan. 15. 2025.

The liberties of Celtic women have been a hot topic for thousands of years. Roman writers were scandalized by reports of their sexual freedoms, which insocicluded taking multiple husbands. Cartimandua and Boudica, early female leaders in Britain, demonstrated that women could reach the highest levels of power, commanding armies and heading tribes.

Archaeological evidence also hints at flexible gender dynamics that varied widely depending on local traditions. For instance, Celtic women were sometimes buried with luxurious grave goods, like jewelry and mirrors, a marker of high status. Patrilocality, whereby women live near their in-laws, is still far more culturally common, but female-centric societies are not as unheard-of as they were even a decade ago.

“It’s a generational paradigm shift,” said Rachel Pope, an associate professor in European prehistory at the University of Liverpool with expertise in matrilocality who was not involved in the study. “It’s partly a trend in archaeology more generally, where we have returned to data and material evidence to lead narrative, rather than imposing narratives that confirm our own biases.”

In other words, scientists are working on big data projects, such as genome analysis, to pin down patterns in social structures with a level of accuracy that cannot be obtained from other sources like the accounts of classical writers with their own agendas and biases

Friday, April 26, 2024

Take your kids to work day – to Mt. Kenya [Don't punish women scientists because they have kids]

Toby Kiers, A Simple Act of Defiance Can Improve Science for Women, NYTimes, April 26, 2024.

sci

They don’t tell you beforehand that it will be a choice between having a career in science or starting a family. But that’s the message I heard loud and clear 17 years ago, in my first job after completing my Ph.D. in evolutionary biology. During a routine departmental meeting, a senior academic announced that pregnant women were a financial drain on the department. I was sitting visibly pregnant in the front row. No one said anything.

She has another child. There are incidents: "It felt like an impossible choice: to be a bad scientist or a bad mother."

What to do:

Through an act of academic defiance: I bring my kids with me on my scientific expeditions. It’s a form of rebellion that is available to mothers not just in the sciences but also in other disciplines that require site visits and field work, such as architecture and journalism. [...]

It started for me as a simple necessity. When my son was just under 2 and my daughter not yet 4, I took them on an expedition to the base of Mount Kenya in Africa, to study how fungi help trees defend themselves against the elephants and giraffes who feed on them. My son was still nursing, and I didn’t want to stop working. My husband, a poet, came along to stay with them at base camp.

As time went on, I began to embrace the decision to bring my kids with me on my expeditions, not as an exigency of parenting but as a kind of feminist act.

It has worked out well:

I started tasting soils in the field — a technique I now use to notice subtle differences across ecosystems — only after seeing my kids eat dirt. Children have an uncanny ability to make local friends quickly; many of those new friends have led me to obscure terrain and hidden fungal oases that I otherwise would never have come across. And my kids’ naïve minds routinely force me to rethink old assumptions by asking questions that are simultaneously absurd and profound. Can you taste clouds? Do fungi dream? How loud are our footsteps underground?

And so it goes. More examples of how things worked out.

At its core, feminism is about having the power to choose. For female scientists, this means having the ability to bring children into the field — or the full support to leave them at home. The pressure is acute because, as research shows, women on scientific teams are significantly less likely than men to be credited with authorship. So for me, it is crucial to keep collecting data with my own hands.

There's much more at the link.

Saturday, February 24, 2024

Morales, Birds of Paradise | Indiana University Trumpet Ensemble

When I was in high school in the 1960s there were 15 or 17 trumpet players, I forget exactly how many, in the marching and concert bands. Only two of them were female. This trumpet ensemble from Indiana University, which has an excellent brass program, has six young women. The times they have changed.

Saturday, January 20, 2024

On the history and connotations of "maestro"

Over at Language Log Victor Mair quotes at length from an article written by Holly Mathieson, the Music Director of the Symphony of Nova Scotia. After reviewing the word's etymological history, Mathieson goes into its cultural history;

However, I think the cultural history of “maestro” is even more fascinating, and certainly has a far greater bearing on my thoughts about its modern usage. Along with words like masterful, masterpiece, and genius – all three of which are also inherently gendered, etymologically – the concept of the maestro was also inseparable from certain racial and class profiles, not least because through the centuries of its usage, it denoted values and opportunities afforded only to wealthy, abled males from dominant (European) cultures.

In the 20th century, beyond a demographic truism, the term came to be synonymous with the sort of toxic hierarchical and tyrannical behaviour that was fetishized in the popular image of conductors like Arturo Toscanini and Herbert von Karajan. On the surface, it makes for a slightly outlandish “demanding genius” caricature, on which many very ordinary conductors were (and are) happy to trade. But beneath the marketing hype, it also led to gross abuses of power, predatory sexual behaviour, and a pervasive culture of bullying and autocracy. Unfortunately, it still plays out in the often-unhealthy relationship between orchestras and conductors, and the incredibly outdated pay-scale differential between superstar conductors and the players they work with.

I can't help but thinking of that in the context of the current movie, Maestro, which I've been blogging about recently. I've read a number of comments from about the film and about Bernstein; all thought highly of him. But few, if indeed any, of those were from musicians who had worked with him. The movie certainly doesn't depict him as behaving tyrannically toward the musicians he worked with, but then we don't see all that much of him actually working with them as opposed to conducting performances. Two scenes come to mind. One is at an open rehearsal with the Philharmonic, where we see him talking to the audience, but not interacting with the musicians. The other scene is close to the end where he's working with a young conductor at Tanglewood, which whom he dances later at a party. There he's only interacting with the student, and its the student who interacts with the orchestra. I've seen a fair amount of rehearsal footage of Bernstein and he doesn't seem tyrannical there. But off-stage, how was he there?

FWIW, I'm on a trumpet player's listserve and I've read many stories of orchestral trumpet players standing up to conductors.

Tuesday, January 9, 2024

A Systematic Review and New Analyses of the Gender-Equality Paradox

Herlitz, A., Hönig, I., Hedebrant, K., & Asperholm, M. (2024). A Systematic Review and New Analyses of the Gender-Equality Paradox. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1177/17456916231202685

Abstract: Some studies show that living conditions, such as economy, gender equality, and education, are associated with the magnitude of psychological sex differences. We systematically and quantitatively reviewed 54 articles and conducted new analyses on 27 meta-analyses and large-scale studies to investigate the association between living conditions and psychological sex differences. We found that sex differences in personality, verbal abilities, episodic memory, and negative emotions are more pronounced in countries with higher living conditions. In contrast, sex differences in sexual behavior, partner preferences, and math are smaller in countries with higher living conditions. We also observed that economic indicators of living conditions, such as gross domestic product, are most sensitive in predicting the magnitude of sex differences. Taken together, results indicate that more sex differences are larger, rather than smaller, in countries with higher living conditions. It should therefore be expected that the magnitude of most psychological sex differences will remain unchanged or become more pronounced with improvements in living conditions, such as economy, gender equality, and education.

H/t Tyler Cowen.

Tuesday, October 10, 2023

Claudia Goldin on tenure, happiness, and other matters

Claudian Goldin is an economics historian who just won a Nobel. Tyler Cowen had a conversation with her back in 2021. I’ve picked out a few bits that particularly interested me, but there’s much more to the conversation.

Tenure

Following a long and interesting general discussion of the pay gap between men and women they focused on the position of female academics in economics. And that led to some remarks on tenure.

COWEN: How is the gender ratio for tenured economics professors evolving?

GOLDIN: CSWEP, that is, the American Economic Association Committee on the Status of Women in the Economics Profession, puts together those data, and they are creeping upward, as one would think they would. Now, in some very interesting work, we can see that they are — I said the words “creeping up.” They’re not bounding up.

The reason that they’re not bounding up at first we thought was a pipeline issue, but now it’s pretty clear that it’s less the pipeline issue. While it was there and still is there, there’s also an issue with the fact that women — more than men — will leave academia and use their economic skills extremely well but outside the tenure track.

COWEN: Should we either abolish tenure or fundamentally change it so as not to penalize women, but also for other reasons? It seems grossly unfair.

GOLDIN: Yes, I certainly wouldn’t do it because it’s a penalty for one group or another. It is an issue that arose. It solved potentially an issue from some time ago. I don’t know if the fundamentals are the same that would support it. It is clearly a difficult problem in the sense that individuals have higher productivity when they’re young and then lower productivity. I think that having long-term contracts is useful for individuals in fields where they’re so good.

If we think about sports, clearly those people just clean up at the beginning, and then they become used-car salesmen or whatever they become. So the question is, do we have a completely changed academic environment in which the superstars clean up at some point and then they go into something else? I don’t think that that would work either.

I think that a very important thing to think about is that we produce a large number of products. We produce knowledge, and that’s really the hardest thing to figure out how to do, but we produce the dissemination of knowledge and teaching. And people who are older probably do that better, and that is not generally what tenure is given for.

Happiness

That led immediately to these remarks on happiness:

COWEN: I’m sure you know the [Betsey] Stevenson and [Justin] Wolfers paper, 2009. Why haven’t American women gained more in happiness?

GOLDIN: [laughs] See, I’m not a great fan of that. I remember Betsey was interviewed on Mother’s Day one year. She was a new mother. The person interviewing her said, “Your work shows that mothers are less happy than they had been before they became mothers.” The person said, “That was a great question for Mother’s Day.” Betsey was stuck, and she said, “Well, yes, but they would never give up their baby.” I think that for me, as an economist, that says it all. There’s some problem.

COWEN: So, you think it’s not true that American women are less happy than they had been? I’m not sure what your stance is.

GOLDIN: My stance is that I’m not happy with the happiness measures.

COWEN: Do you think there’s something else they’re not picking up?

GOLDIN: Yes.

COWEN: That’s an ordinal-choice thing rather than stress in the moment?

GOLDIN: Yes.

COWEN: And that if people are choosing something out of a greater set of opportunities, they probably are happier?

GOLDIN: That’s right. It’s very hard to do that in general. Sometimes we rile up a group and get them to remember the things that they’re less happy about, and sometimes we show them where their lives are safe and secure and wonderful and plentiful, and then they get happier.

I remember when Dick Easterlin first began the happiness literature. I remember very, very well — it was a very long time ago — having dinner with him in Madison, Wisconsin, and talking about it. I was enthralled with trying to understand this happiness literature.

That was across countries, and it seemed interesting, from my Chicago theory point of view, that people recenter their happiness. You can be in a place in which, if you were plunked down there from somewhere else, you’d be miserable, and yet, you’re there, and you recalibrate yourself, just like people recalibrate themselves when they have a bad health event. It takes a while. I’m not certain what to do with the happiness literature.

This business of recalibration made me think of Miriam Yevick, who set out to be a research mathematician but ended up teaching remedial math to adults. She seemed quite happy with that. In my recent 3 Quarks Daily essay about Yevick I remarked that that seemed like Goethe’s Faust, “who sought the secrets of the universe in his youth [...] but ended up reclaiming land from the sea in old age.”

There’s much more in the interview.

Monday, August 9, 2021

What We Teach About Race and Gender: Representation in Images and Text of Children’s Books

The abstract of the linked article:

Books shape how children learn about society and social norms, in part through the representation of different characters. To better understand the messages children encounter in books, we introduce new artificial intelligence methods for systematically converting images into data. We apply these image tools, along with established text analysis methods, to measure the representation of race, gender, and age in children’s books commonly found in US schools and homes over the last century. We find that more characters with darker skin color appear over time, but "mainstream" award-winning books, which are twice as likely to be checked out from libraries, persistently depict more lighter-skinned characters even after conditioning on perceived race. Across all books, children are depicted with lighter skin than adults. Over time, females are increasingly present but are more represented in images than in text, suggesting greater symbolic inclusion in pictures than substantive inclusion in stories. Relative to their growing share of the US population, Black and Latinx people are underrepresented in the mainstream collection; males, particularly White males, are persistently overrepresented. Our data provide a view into the "black box" of education through children’s books in US schools and homes, highlighting what has changed and what has endured.

Saturday, August 7, 2021

The stories we tell our boys do not prepare them for living and interacting with other people

Ruth Whippman, What We Are Not Teaching Boys About Being Human, NYTimes, August 6, 2021,

The lack of positive people-focused stories for boys has consequences both for them and girls. In the narratives they consume, as well as the broader cultural landscape in which they operate, girls get a huge head start on relational skills, in the day-to-day thorniness and complexity of emotional life. Story by story, girls are getting the message that other people’s feelings are their concern and their responsibility. Boys are learning that these things have nothing to do with them. More on boys, men and culture

We have barely even registered this lack of an emotional and relational education as a worrying loss for boys. We tend to dismiss and trivialize teenage girls’ preoccupation with the intricacies of relationships as “girl-drama.” But as Niobe Way, a professor of psychology at New York University and the author of “Deep Secrets, Boys’ Friendships and the Crisis of Connection” says, “When we devalue things associated with femininity — such as emotions and relationships — boys miss out.”

The imbalance doesn’t just put exhausting pressure on girls and women to bear the social and emotional load of life — to remember the birthdays and wipe the tears and understand that Grandma’s increasingly aggressive eyebrow twitch means that she needs to be separated from Aunt Susan — it harms boys and men, too. They are missing out on internalizing concepts and learning skills crucial to a connected, moral, psychologically healthy life.

Probably because of this difference in socialization, boys score lower than girls of the same age on virtually all measures of empathy and social skills, a gap that grows throughout childhood and adolescence. This has implications across the board. Among first graders, social emotional ability, including the skills to form and maintain friendships, is a greater predictor of academic success than either family background or cognitive skills. Boys are now lagging behind girls academically at every grade level through college, so providing them with a more nuanced and people-focused emotional world — in what they read and watch, and in the conversations we have with them — might go some way toward closing that gap.

The impact on boys’ mental health is also likely to be significant. From a young age, girls’ friendships tend to be more intimate, deeper and more emotionally focused, providing a support structure that is often sorely lacking for boys. According to the American Psychological Association, this lack of support, and the masculinity norms that underpin it, can contribute to a range of serious mental health problems. Adolescent boys are also at almost twice the risk for death by suicide than girls — so this is an urgent problem.

Tuesday, March 10, 2020

Oprah and Trump, two sides of the same coin?

Natasha Zaretsky, The Odd Couple: Donald Trump, Oprah Winfrey, and Contemporary Charisma, The Hedgehog Review, Spring 2020:
How, then, do we explain the respective charismas of Oprah Winfrey and Donald Trump? I propose that their charismatic powers make sense only in light of the dramatic shift in authority relations that has been underway since the 1970s. During the last five decades, traditional racial, gender, and sexual hierarchies have toppled as women, people of color, and sexual minorities have gained greater visibility in public life. At the same time, economic and social inequality has sharpened while the distribution of wealth has become precariously asymmetrical, workers’ rights have been obliterated, and public goods like health care, education, and housing have been degraded. We thus find ourselves moving simultaneously forward and backward in time: forward into a public sphere that is more gender egalitarian, more multiracial, and more sexually capacious; and backward into a winner-take-all economy and culture that is often described as a new Gilded Age. This backward-forward motion is the product of a comprehensive shift in authority relations. Some, such as those within the traditional family, have loosened, while others, such as those that revolve around property, have tightened. This is what we might call the neoliberal paradox, and it is a defining feature of our time.

On the surface, it appears that Winfrey and Trump reflect the two sides of this paradox, with Winfrey capturing the dissolution of traditional gender and racial hierarchies and Trump symbolizing the boss’s ever-tightening grip. But Winfrey and Trump are not oppositional figures. Rather, each signals the simultaneously occurring breakdown of patriarchal authority and consolidation of market forces throughout the society. Consequently, Winfrey and Trump work with rather than against each other by accelerating a historical transition underway in the late capitalist family and workplace.

Winfrey and Trump harnessed the energies unleashed by the gender revolution of the late twentieth century to consolidate their charismatic authority. Over the course of their careers, they have used the medium of television to translate these energies into lessons for their followers about how to navigate life in workplaces that are at once more meritocratic and more predatory. Ultimately, as contemporary charismatic leaders par excellence, Winfrey and Trump fulfill a crucial need among their devotees: They guide them as they live through the dissolution of patriarchy and the intensification of market fundamentalism and economic inequality.
At the end of the article:
If we take seriously Weber’s insights about charismatic authority, the two charismas of Winfrey and Trump track both the breakdown of patriarchal authority and the consolidation of market domination in contemporary life. This tale of two charismas reveals that twenty-first-century capitalism legitimates itself in the midst of so much predation by manipulating and exploiting the antiauthoritarian energies unleashed by the gender revolution, harnessing those energies rather than suppressing them. Even as Winfrey and Trump appeared estranged from the social movements that took off in the 1960s, both drew on those movements without realizing that that was what they were doing. And both relied on the intimate, pervasive medium of television to reroute the energies of those movements in ways that have ended up strengthening the winner-take-all ethos of market fundamentalism in our social and cultural imaginary.

It may be tempting to see Winfrey as the embodiment of everything good about our age and Trump as the embodiment of everything bad. But in the end, both endorse the same belief: that there are only winners and losers. Winfrey’s cruelty is shrouded in therapeutic language, while Trump is bald-faced about the brute forces that pervade society. The world according to Trump is one of tough operators and cutthroat financial killers, “the kind of people who leave blood all over the boardroom table.”26 While most American workers today do not move in Trump’s circles, they do inhabit workplaces where, no matter how hard they work, their fates are determined by forces beyond their control, and they experience life as largely a series of accidents, contingencies, lucky breaks, and sudden reversals of fortune.

Winfrey rejects this grim take on the winner-take-all society. While she rose to fame by tearing back the curtain on the ugly side of heterosexual relations, she has gone on to cultivate a self-help philosophy that insists that people create their own realities. Winfrey hates the concept of luck and considers herself in touch with the divine. “Luck is a matter of preparation,” she has said. “I am highly attuned to my divine self.” The callousness of this perspective came into sharp relief when she once suggested to Elie Wiesel that his survival at Auschwitz constituted a direct miracle from God. “If a miracle of God to spare me, why?” he countered. “There were people much better than me…. No, it was an accident.”

In Winfrey’s world there are no accidents; everything happens for a reason. In Trump’s world, might makes right and coercion rules. Trump’s worldview resonates with the lived experiences of workers, while also trafficking in the seductive fantasy that a baby can become the boss. Winfrey also offers a fantasy figure: a guardian angel with whose help working people imagine they might escape. But neither a dealmaker nor a fairy godmother offers us a way out of our new Gilded Age.

Monday, November 25, 2019

The Great British Baking Show [my mother had skills] [Media Notes 21]

A couple of weeks ago I started watching The Great British Baking Show – known as the Great British Bake Off, Bake Off, or GBBO in Britain. I learned about it in a tweet by Hollis Robbins, who raved about it, so I figured: Why not? After all, I like a good fruit pie, or a sticky bun, not to mention a loaf of bread – I still remember the bread we ate one morning on Canada’s Gaspé Peninsula during a family vacation over a half a century ago: Heaven. Alas, but only remember, not taste.

I will say that I do find GBBO interesting, but I don’t feel compelled to binge it, and I wonder about the format of these cooking competitions, as this is the only one I’ve even as much as a full episode. I’m currently eight episodes into the second season of the seven available on the Netflix. But mostly I think about the things my mother baked, about her skills, and I wonder how she’d do in such a competition.

If I had to guess, I’d guess that she wouldn’t even have been chosen as a contestant, and yet I believe that, within her range, she could bake as well as anyone on the show, even the esteemed judges. I’ve never had anything that goes by the name of “Danish pastry” that’s as good as hers, made according to a recipe she learned from her Danish mother-in-law (who was of course be my grandmother), and I’ve eaten a lot of Danish over the years. I’ve not made any attempt to scout out the best Danish available on this side of the Hudson River in Jersey City or Hoboken, the two places where I’ve lived for the last twenty years. Possibly it would be as good as my mothers’. Possibly. This are of New Jersey, after all, effectively functions as set of neighborhoods in New York City. I’d be surprised if Manhattan didn’t have Danish that good, though I’m not sure I’d want to pay the price. And should the Big Apple cough up some Danish that’s even better, ah, well, I can’t imagine that possible, it’s a matter of taste, isn’t it? And if it did – but how could I judge as it’s been so long since I’ve eaten my mother’s wienerbrød – wouldn’t that be delightful?

You see my problem, don’t you?

This is supposed to be about GBBO and I’m all tangled up in my mother’s pastry skills. For what she did, she was superb. But her range was circumscribed, something I realized during my teens. Why did she always follow a recipe? Why not make up something of her own? Those questions only had any bite because they implied that she could perfectly well break out if she choose to do so. She certainly had the skills, the talent (whatever that is). But not the will, or is it imagination?

(Could it be that she did so and I didn’t notice?)

That circumscription is what would have kept her off GBBO. If you ask me why her range was circumscribed, why she didn’t exercise her imagination, her will, well, that was long ago and far away and I was young and bound up in my own life challenges. But it’s not as though I haven’t a clue. She was a traditional housewife, willing to live within those boundaries, but how do I begin to write and think about that without getting entangled in the crossings between our family life – mother, father, my sister, and me – which are none of your business, and the psycho-cultural dynamics of men’s and women’s roles (not to mention children) in our society. Those dynamics, of course, are of great interest and importance and are still very much under negotiation and transformation.

Moreover, how can I discuss those dynamics in connection with The Great British Baking Show if I don’t have a broader knowledge of the conventions of the competitive cooking show? GBBO is surely a competition. There are three rounds in each episode; the contestants are judged after each one, with comments. At the end of the episode one contestant is crowned Star Baker and another is dropped from the competition. At the same time it feels like a group of friends getting together to bake for one another, share recipes, and drink some tea – except that we don’t see any onscreen tea drinking. Camaraderie in competition, group hugs for those cast off.

Are all these televised cooking competitions like that? I doubt it, but I don’t know. In order to understand what I’m seeing on the screen don’t I need a sense of the range of conventions and behaviors in which the show operates? For some purposes, definitely. But those aren’t the only purposes, are they? I could report what I see.

And what I see is a lot of baked goods I’d like to be eating, though not all. Some sweet, most of them sweet, but some savory as well. Contestants ranging in age from early twenties well into high middle age edging into old. Both men and women, the ratio is important, but I’ve not been keeping track. I do note, though, that in season two all the men had been dropped by episode eight, or was it seven? Why’s the ratio important? Within the range of cooking disciplines, aren’t breads and pastries coded as female while entrees, sides, and appetizers – the main meal – coded as male? So within the world of cooking competitions that would code a bake off as female while competition over meats, veggies, and the rest would be coded as male.

You see my problem, don’t you?

Well, you see part of it anyhow. There’s also the fact that we’re almost 900 words in and I’ve only discussed my mother’s Danish pastry, and that not very well. Do you have any idea how much work is involved in making it, all the folding? Do you appreciate the tang cardamom seeds give it? They don’t use cardamom seeds in Greek-diner Danish. Nor have I gotten around to the wonders of her pie crust, the variety of cookies she made at Christmas, and the pasty. Do you know what pasty is? It’s a savory meat pie, meat and potatoes. The crust uses suet rather than lard for shortening – makes it chewy. The miners in Cornwall – where my mother’s people are from – would take a couple pasties with them into the mines. It’s peasant food. Nothing fancy about it.

I haven’t seen any pasty so far on this bake off. Do they get around to it in a later episode? Granted, it’s not the sort of thing you’re tempted to craft into a chocolate cow jumping over a lemon merengue moon, a gingerbread approximation to a Quidditch court, or even a spun sugar waterfall tumbling over an angel food cliff into a sea of blueberry jam, but it’s filling and it tastes good. At least when it’s made the way my mother made it.

And of course it’s British. According to Wikipedia “it is regarded as the national dish and accounts for 6% of the Cornish food economy.” Not only that, it has been given Protected Geographical Indication (PGI) status in Europe. What happens to that if Brexit succeeds?

I digress.

By the way, did I mention her jams and jellies? And that Danish rhubarb pudding she made using rhubarb from the back yard and the almond slivers and a name I could never pronounce and hence haven’t a ghost of a chance on a guess at the spelling?

Pssst. I googled. It’s Rabarbergrød.

Monday, August 19, 2019

Joe Rogan and his middle-bro audience

Devin Gordon, Why is Joe Rogan so Popular? The Atlantic, August 2019.

The podcast:
Rogan’s podcast gushes like a mighty river of content—approximately three episodes a week, usually more than two hours per episode, consisting of one marathon conversation with a subject of his choosing. Over the course of about 1,400 episodes and counting, his roster of guests can be divided roughly three ways: (1) comedians, (2) fighters, and (3) “thinkers,” which requires air quotes because it encompasses everyone from Oxford scholars and MIT bioengineers to culture drivers such as the marketing entrepreneur Hotep Jesus and the rapper turned radio co-host Charlamagne tha God all the way across the known intellectual galaxy to conspiracy theorists like Rogan’s longtime buddy and Sandy Hook denier Alex Jones. Also Dr. Phil. And David Lee Roth. And B-Real from Cypress Hill.

It’s impossible to be a Joe Rogan completist, so most of his fans pick a few tributaries. The rest may as well not exist. Who can keep track? Rogan is a key figure in the rise of MMA—Dana White once called him “the best fight announcer who has ever called a fight in the history of fighting”—but I don’t care about fighting, so I didn’t listen to any of Joe’s podcasts with fighters. I also didn’t listen to Dr. Phil, and I’m sure I’m not the only one who skipped it, which is just another way of saying there’s no real way to describe “Joe Rogan fans.” They’re not aligned around any narrow set of curiosities or politics. They’re aligned around Joe.
The audience:
As popular as he seems to be with quote-unquote regular guys, that’s how unpopular Joe Rogan is with the quote-unquote prestige wing of popular culture—Emmy voters, HBO subscribers, comedy nerds. Thought leaders. Thought followers. There are plenty of Joe Rogan fans among them, too, but they tend not to bring it up. [...]

The bedrock issue, though, is Rogan’s courting of a middle-bro audience that the cultural elite hold in particular contempt—guys who get barbed-wire tattoos and fill their fridge with Monster energy drinks and preordered their tickets to see Hobbs & Shaw. Joe loves these guys, and his affection has none of the condescension and ironic distance many people fall back on in order to get comfortable with them. He shares their passions and enthusiasms at a moment when the public dialogue has branded them childish or problematic or a slippery slope to Trumpism. Like many of these men, Joe grumbles a lot about “political correctness.” He knows that he is privileged by virtue of his gender and his skin color, but in his heart he is sick of being reminded about it. Like lots of other white men in America, he is grappling with a growing sense that the term white man has become an epithet. And like lots of other men in America, not just the white ones, he’s reckoning out loud with a fear that the word masculinity has become, by definition, toxic.

Most of Rogan’s critics don’t really grasp the breadth and depth of the community he has built, and they act as though trying is pointless.
Technique and craft:
The hard truth for some of Rogan’s critics in the media is that he is much better at captivating audiences than most of us, because he has the patience and the generosity to let his interviews be an experience rather than an inquisition. And, go figure, his approach has the virtue of putting his subjects at ease and letting the conversation go to poignant places, like the moment when Musk reflected on what it was like to be Elon Musk as a child—his brain a set of bagpipes that blared all day and all night. He assumed he would wind up in a mental institution. “It may sound great if it’s turned on,” he said in his blunt mechanical way, “but what if it doesn’t turn off?”
Limitations:
And a key thing Joe and his fans tend to have in common is a deficit of empathy. He seems unable to process how his tolerance for monsters like Alex Jones plays a role in the wounding of people who don’t deserve it. Jones’s recent appearance on the podcast came after he was sued by families of children and educators murdered in the Sandy Hook massacre—a mass shooting that Jones falsely claimed was a hoax, which families of the victims say prompted his gang of fans to harass them. (Jones has since acknowledged that the Sandy Hook massacre occurred.) So is Joe really nurturing a generation of smarter, healthier, more worldly men, or an army of conspiracy theorists and alt-right super soldiers? At the very least, he shows too much compassion for bad actors, and not enough for people on the receiving end of their attacks. [...] More revealing is who he invites onto his podcast, and what subjects he chooses to feast on in his stand-up specials. And if you cast a wide enough net, clear patterns emerge. If there’s a woman or a person of color (or both) on Joe’s podcast, the odds are high that person is a fighter or an entertainer, and not a public intellectual.
And so:
My Joe Rogan experience ended because he wore me out. He never shuts up. He talks and talks and talks. He doesn’t seem to grasp that not every thought inside his brain needs to be said out loud. It doesn’t occur to him to consider whether his contributions have value. He just speaks his mind. He just whips it out and drops it on the table.

Monday, February 11, 2019

Home socialization and gender preferences in math

Gaia Dossi, David N. Figlio, Paola Giuliano, Paola Sapienza, Born in the Family: Preferences for Boys and the Gender Gap in Math, NBER Working Paper, No. 25535
Issued in February 2019:
Abstract: We study the correlation between parental gender attitudes and the performance in mathematics of girls using two different approaches and data. First, we identify families with a preference for boys by using fertility stopping rules in a population of households whose children attend public schools in Florida. Girls growing up in a boy-biased family score 3 percentage points lower on math tests when compared to girls raised in other families. Second, we find similar strong effects when we study the correlations between girls’ performance in mathematics and maternal gender role attitudes, using evidence from the National Longitudinal Survey of Youth. We conclude that socialization at home can explain a non-trivial part of the observed gender disparities in mathematics performance and document that maternal gender attitudes correlate with those of their children, supporting the hypothesis that preferences transmitted through the family impact children behavior.

Sunday, June 19, 2016

Sex? What's the Difference? It's not binary; it's complex.

Claire Ainsworth in Nature, from February 15, 2016:
Sex can be much more complicated than it at first seems. According to the simple scenario, the presence or absence of a Y chromosome is what counts: with it, you are male, and without it, you are female. But doctors have long known that some people straddle the boundary — their sex chromosomes say one thing, but their gonads (ovaries or testes) or sexual anatomy say another. Parents of children with these kinds of conditions — known as intersex conditions, or differences or disorders of sex development (DSDs) — often face difficult decisions about whether to bring up their child as a boy or a girl. Some researchers now say that as many as 1 person in 100 has some form of DSD2.

When genetics is taken into consideration, the boundary between the sexes becomes even blurrier. Scientists have identified many of the genes involved in the main forms of DSD, and have uncovered variations in these genes that have subtle effects on a person's anatomical or physiological sex. What's more, new technologies in DNA sequencing and cell biology are revealing that almost everyone is, to varying degrees, a patchwork of genetically distinct cells, some with a sex that might not match that of the rest of their body. Some studies even suggest that the sex of each cell drives its behaviour, through a complicated network of molecular interactions. “I think there's much greater diversity within male or female, and there is certainly an area of overlap where some people can't easily define themselves within the binary structure,” says John Achermann, who studies sex development and endocrinology at University College London's Institute of Child Health.

These discoveries do not sit well in a world in which sex is still defined in binary terms. Few legal systems allow for any ambiguity in biological sex, and a person's legal rights and social status can be heavily influenced by whether their birth certificate says male or female.
The final two paragraphs:
Yet if biologists continue to show that sex is a spectrum, then society and state will have to grapple with the consequences, and work out where and how to draw the line. Many transgender and intersex activists dream of a world where a person's sex or gender is irrelevant. Although some governments are moving in this direction, Greenberg is pessimistic about the prospects of realizing this dream — in the United States, at least. “I think to get rid of gender markers altogether or to allow a third, indeterminate marker, is going to be difficult.”

So if the law requires that a person is male or female, should that sex be assigned by anatomy, hormones, cells or chromosomes, and what should be done if they clash? “My feeling is that since there is not one biological parameter that takes over every other parameter, at the end of the day, gender identity seems to be the most reasonable parameter,” says Vilain. In other words, if you want to know whether someone is male or female, it may be best just to ask.

Monday, November 10, 2014

The Anime Paradox: Why so many strong and imaginative female characters when Japanese society is paternalistic and sexist?

One of the attractive features of anime, and manga as well, is the wealth of strong women and girls. Yes, they may be kawaii to the max, but they are also smart, creative, and can kick ass when needed. But Japan is not at all a feminist utopia. Not even remotely so.

For example, here are some informal remarks by one Patrick McKenzie, an expatriate American living and working in Japan. He's explaining how employment works in Japan:
A salaryman (transliterated from the Japanese which is itself borrowed from English), more formally a “full-time company employee” (正社員), is the local equivalent of a W-2 employee in America. This is roughly 1/3rd of the labor force in Japan, but it has outsized societal impact.

Traditionally, salarymen (and they are, by the way, mostly men) are hired into a particular company late in university and stay at that company or its affiliates until they retire.

There are other workers at Japanese companies — contract employees, who can be (and are) let go at will, or young ladies on the “pink collar” track who are encouraged tacitly or explicitly to quit to get married or raise children — but the salaryman/employer relationship is the beating heart of the high-productivity Japanese private sector. (The Japanese economy is roughly 1/3rd the public sector, 1/3rd low-productivity firms like restaurants or traditional craftsmen, and 1/3rd high-productivity household-name megacorps. Salarymen are mostly present in the last one, which happens to dovetail with your professional interests.)
Since a salaryman's company monopolizes his time, it will helpfully find him a wife:
Don’t have a wife? You might quite reasonably think “I don’t have time to even think about that.” Don’t worry — the company will fix your social calendar for you. It is socially mandatory that your boss, in fulfillment of his duties to you, sees that you are set up with a young lady appropriate to your station. He is likely to attempt to do this first by matching you with a young lady in your office. There are, at all times, a number of unattached young ladies in your office. Most of them choose to quit right about when they get married or have children.

You might imagine that you heard a supervisor tell a young lady in the office “Hey, you’re 30 and aging out of the marriage market, plus I hear you’re dating someone who is not one of my employees, so you might want to think about moving on soon.”, but that would be radioactively illegal, since Japanese employment discrimination laws are approximately equivalent to those in the US. A first-rate Japanese company would certainly never do anything illegal, and a proper Japanese salaryman would never bring his company into disrepute by saying obviously untrue things like the company is systematically engaged in illegal practices. So your ears must be deceiving you. Pesky ears.
What happens to a young woman who was raised on the exploits of, say, Cardcaptor Sakura, or any of the feisty heroines in Miyazaki films? Well, you might get a job in a start-up, which is pretty much outside the salaryman system. McKenzie advises Japanese entrepreneurs:
Since most highly-educated, career-oriented Japanese folks aspire to jobs as salarymen or similar work in the public sector, most Japanese startups have to hire folks who don’t fit that mold.

Some examples include:

Women: I may have mentioned alluded to the fact that traditionally managed Japanese companies are pathological with regards to their treatment of women. There’s an entire academic field devoted to that topic. Anyhow, this is an opportunity for startups here: since college-educated women are tremendously underused by the formal labor market, startups can attract them preferentially.
What gives?

Elizabethan English seems a bit like that, at least through the lens of Shakespeare. He created some wonder strong women – Beatrice (Much Ado About Nothing), Portia (Merchant of Venice), Cleopatra (Antony and Cleopatra) – but Elizabethan England as patriarchal and sexist. To be sure, the monarch was a Queen, and one of the greatest monarchs in British history, but that's only one woman.

I certainly don't believe that fiction mirrors society in any direct way. But why do we have these vibrant female characters that are so much against the prevailing social grain?