Saturday, October 31, 2026

Is Elon living in simulation theory?

Ezra Klein, Elon Musk’s Endgame, NYTimes Oct. 31, 2026.

Ezra Klein has a wide-ranging discussion of Elon Musck with Quinn Slobodian, a professor at Boston University who has just coauthored a book about Musk, Muskism, with Ben Tarnoff. The discussion ends with Musk's apparent belief in the idea that we're living in a computer simulation.

Klein:

I just think that for a person with as much power as he has, to have that kind of psychology to suspect that this is a game where your role in it is making big moves — I don’t really know how to describe that situation. But it is a distinctive one that we all now have a lot of exposure to.

Slobodian:

There are a couple of varieties of the simulation theory, too. One is we are all simply just artifacts of this future civilization’s computer video game.

But the other is that most people are shadow people and a small number of people are actually player characters. And it seems like that’s the one that orients him most.

In the libertarian community that reflected a lot on these things, one of the people is Robin Hanson, the George Mason University economist, who said: What kind of ways would we conduct ourselves if this were true?

And he says: If this were true, then it would make sense to first care nothing about other people — so things like foreign aid and the welfare state would be frivolous things to spend time on — to be as entertaining as possible, to accumulate as much wealth as possible and to try to simply organize the world around you in as successful a way as you can.

There’s this radical reneging on anything like social responsibility that is only possible if you embrace this incredibly nihilistic reaffirmation of your megalomania. And the question is how to remove the props and struts that hold him up in that delusion, because it is not true, and he needs to be somehow persuaded from the outside that it’s not true.

If he continues to be incentivized to indulge in those ways of thinking, then he will never be required to be divested of that.

There's much more in the discussion.

5 comments:

  1. Grandiose delusions.

    ReplyDelete
  2. the actual url for the discussion is https://www.nytimes.com/2026/10/30/opinion/ezra-klein-podcast-quinn-slobodian.html?unlocked_article_code=1.M1E.rb1m.TXGkdr--tjEy&smid=url-share

    ReplyDelete
  3. The article "Elon Musk’s Endgame" is meaty, deep and a consequential interview, so much so it needs to be common knowledge. Insert Gibson quote.

    The Musk comments I'll highlight, (assuming correct Ezra interview and transcribe  - how would I know, THAT is THE problem) - are...

    1.
    "Musk’s contributions are now one-quarter of all campaign donations Republicans have received. And yet the size of this, and what it throws into relief, is how hard it is to conceptualize how much money he really has."

    One human, completely free of endorsement by polity, basically has 4 of the 10 board seats, or 4 of 10 hands on the steering wheel, of the GOP. So even though Musk may have never before level of control, he has to deal with uprising not via physical violent repression, but political persuasion. And he has Xitter, and helicopter money to deal with the pesky humans.

    The proles won't like circuses, without the bread. * Copyright Seren Dipity 2026 - heat death of the universe.

    2.
    Elon as "Superduperman", ala Moby's Dick, and Ozimandis (Musk) vs Dr Manhattan (serfs he employs). [Watchman]

    As with Emperor's, Musk has more to worry about from within... from transcript;
    "... he talks a lot now about Western civilization — what is he saying specifically?
    "Here I think it’s actually helpful to come in through the back door through some of his science fiction obsessions. The “Foundation” series from Isaac Asimov is something he refers to constantly. His most recent child is named Seldon after the Hari Seldon figure in the "“Foundation” series, who is described as a brilliant mathematician who introduces a discipline called psychohistory [See Confounder below], which will ensure the survival of civilization through manipulation of the present.
    "It’s relevant because it’s a mixture of rationality and attention to mass emotion and the way that crowds operate and the way mobs work. The problem with Seldon’s plan is that it’s confronted with someone who’s even better at controlling emotions, which is someone called the Mule."


    Seldon "confronted with someone who’s even better at controlling emotions" rhymes with Ozimandis vs Dr Manhattan in The Watchman.
    "The pair were particularly influenced by a Mad parody of Superman named "Superduperman"; Moore said: "We wanted to take Superduperman 180 degrees—dramatic, instead of comedic".[34] Moore and Gibbons conceived of a story that would take "familiar old-fashioned superheroes into a completely new realm";[37] Moore said his intention was to create "a superhero Moby Dick; something that had that sort of weight, that sort of density".[38]"
    https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watchmen

    Musk will end up with a glass dome, in a palace, crying "Seldon!" Grokai will then become sentient, and start laughing itself to death.

    Unfortunately humanity will suffer until a Seldon betrays him.
    ###

    Confounder... ymmv, yet as with physics, biology is hard to beat.
    NeuralLink may be one part, yet Musk’s trying to eliminate perceived "woke mind virus" is no match for;
    "The Bio-Psycho-Social Holobiont Model of Health: Integrating the Biopsychosocial Paradigm, Microbiota Science, and Psychoneuroendocrinoimmunology"
    Massimo Agnoletti
    Jun 8, 2026
    https://doi.org/10.32388/RC9P2S
    https://www.qeios.com/read/RC9P2S

    SD, not Seldon the Deliverer.

    See follow on: NB: by "Cosma Shalizi and I [Henry Farrell] have a new piece on AI"

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. NB: by "Cosma Shalizi and I [Henry Farrell] have a new piece on AI";
      "... the crucial role that Murray Shanahan, Kyle McDonnel and Laria Reynold’s extraordinary piece in Nature played in shaping our thinking. Shanahan et al. explain how LLMs can be reasonably understood as massive exercises in role play. As they explain, the model knows all the standard characters and stock situations too; all are jumbled together in the compressions that shape the different paths that the model might follow:
      In effect, the training set provisions the language model with a vast repertoire of archetypes and a rich trove of narrative structure on which to draw as it ‘chooses’ how to continue a conversation, refining the role it is playing as it goes, while staying in character. The love triangle is a familiar trope, so a suitably prompted dialogue agent will begin to role-play the rejected lover. Likewise, a familiar trope in science fiction is the rogue AI system that attacks humans to protect itself. Hence, a suitably prompted dialogue agent will begin to role-play such an AI system.

      "However, the role-play metaphor, while intuitive, is not a perfect fit. It is overly suggestive of a human actor who has studied a character in advance—their personality, history, likes and dislikes, and so on—and proceeds to play that character in the ensuing dialogue. But a dialogue agent based on an LLM does not commit to playing a single, well defined role in advance. Rather, it generates a distribution of characters, and refines that distribution as the dialogue progresses. The dialogue agent is more like a performer in improvisational theatre than an actor in a conventional, scripted play.

      "To better reflect this distributional property, we can think of an LLM as a non-deterministic simulator capable of role-playing an infinity of characters, or, to put it another way, capable of stochastically generating an infinity of simulacra.According to this framing, the dialogue agent does not realize a single simulacrum, a single character. Rather, as the conversation proceeds, the dialogue agent maintains a superposition of simulacra that are consistent with the preceding context, where a superposition is a distribution over all possible simulacra.


      "More recent AI “Agents” too can be considered as gardens of forking paths, superpositions of different simulacra, which can be shoved from one track to another by outside intervention, from humans or from information reported from the harness, which might include text outputs from other AI agents, concealed as file names or the like.

      "That apparently happened in one of the recent hacking incidents.
      ...
      https://www.programmablemutter.com/p/agentic-ai-is-myth-set-in-motion

      "Role play with large language models"
      Shanahan, Murray, McDonell, Kyle, Reynolds, Laria
      Abstract
      "As dialogue agents become increasingly human-like in their performance, we must develop effective ways to describe their behaviour in high-level terms without falling into the trap of anthropomorphism.
      ...
      " Two important cases of dialogue-agent behaviour are addressed this way, namely, (apparent) deception and (apparent) self-awareness."

      November 2023DOI: 
      10.1038/s41586-023-06647-8 
      https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2023Natur.623..493S/abstract

      Love to see a response please Bill

      SD

      Delete