On the similarities between a kumquat and a MiG: ChatCPT chases analogies

We all know that not so long-ago Geoffrey “AI Godfather” Hinton went up on a mountain where he received a heavy granite tablet. As he was holding it a bolt of lightning struck the tablet, leaving the words “You Are Doomed” carved deeply into its surface. Hinton came down from the mountain, tablet in tow, quit his post at Google, and proceeded to warn the world about the dangers of Superintelligent AI.

In early October of last year he took part in a panel discussion about AI and creativity:

One of his reasons for believing in the impending superintelligence of AI has to do with reasoning by analogy. Starting at about 1:18:10:

GEOFFREY HINTON: Let me give you-- let me give you an example of something creative that GPT-4 can already do that most people can't do.

So we're still trapped in the idea of thinking that logical reasoning is the essence of intelligence when we know that being able to--

TOMASO POGGIO: --but some people.

GEOFFREY HINTON: Well--

TOMASO POGGIO: Yeah.

GEOFFREY HINTON: We know that being able to see analogies, especially remote analogies, is a very important aspect of intelligence. So I asked GPT-4, what has a compost heap got in common with an atom bomb? And GPT-4 nailed it, most people just say nothing.

DEMIS HASSABIS: What did it say? [LAUGHTER]

GEOFFREY HINTON: It started off by saying they're very different energy scales, so on the face of it, they look to be very different. But then it got into chain reactions and how the rate at which they're generating energy increases-- their energy increases the rate at which they generate energy. So it got the idea of a chain reaction. And the thing is, it knows about 10,000 times as much as a person, so it's going to be able to see all sorts of analogies that we can't see.

My initial reaction was: Very clever, very clever indeed! But then I thought, I’ll bet GPT-4 could explicate any analogy you ask it to. The cleverness is in picking the right analogy, not in justifying it. Justifying is easy; coming up with an analogy worth the effort of justification, that’s difficult. If GPT-4 knows 10,000 times as much as a person and it has all that compute, then maybe it can waste time far more extravagantly than any person can afford to. Whatever that is, it’s not intelligence.

So I decided to run a little experiment, not with GPT-4, but with plain old ChatGPT, aka the Chatster. I presented it with ten analogies I thought of rather quickly and asked it to explicate them. It did so, and rather impressively I might add. I then asked it to pick the best ones; it evaded the issue. Rather than trying to prompt it into submission I asked it to tell me which of those things was most like a kumquat. As the title of this post indicates, it choose the MiG, and offered an amusing bit of argumentation on the matter. Is that an example of intelligence creativity? How would GPT-4 respond to those prompts? With even more elaborate justifications? Would it have chosen the MiG as well.

And what about GPT-5? Even more extraneous extravagance? Or will it be clever enough to object, saying:

Those analogies are silly. Don’t waste my valuable time and your electricity. Come back when you have something more intelligent to offer.

That’s how I feel about Hinton’s ideas about creativity and human accomplishment. He may be a genius at coming up with neural network architectures, but his thinking about human creativity and intelligence seems to be the work of an overgrown college sophomore. And he’s not the only one.

You might not want to read the whole transcript. But you should at least look at the analogies I proposed, dip into some of Chatster’s explications, read his typically annoying evasion of my penultimate prompt and then, by all means, read his account of the similarities between a kumquat and a MiG. It’s more fun than a barrel of monkeys.

ChatGPT explicates ten analogies

I am going to present you with a bunch of analogies and I want you to explain them. Some of them may same more plausible than others, but don’t let that bother. Just find analogous features.

Here’s the first one: A kitten and a bicycle.

Certainly! Let's explore the analogy between a kitten and a bicycle:

1. Learning Curve:
• Kitten: Like learning to ride a bicycle, a kitten goes through a learning curve as it develops coordination and balance skills. It starts by stumbling and gradually becomes more adept at moving around.
• Bicycle: When someone first learns to ride a bicycle, there is a learning curve in terms of balance and coordination. Over time, the rider becomes more skilled and comfortable.
2. Independence:
• Kitten: As a kitten grows, it becomes more independent, learning to explore its surroundings and perform activities on its own.
• Bicycle: Riding a bicycle grants a sense of independence, allowing the rider to travel to different places under their control.
3. Care and Maintenance:
• Kitten: Similar to a bicycle requiring maintenance, a kitten needs care, including feeding, grooming, and veterinary attention.
• Bicycle: Regular maintenance is essential for a bicycle to function smoothly. This involves checking and adjusting various components, such as the tires, brakes, and gears.
4. Playfulness:
• Kitten: Kittens are known for their playful nature, exploring their environment and engaging in playful activities.
• Bicycle: Riding a bicycle can be a form of recreation and play, especially for leisure rides or sports.
5. Adaptability:
• Kitten: Kittens can adapt to various environments and situations, showcasing their flexibility.
• Bicycle: Bicycles are versatile and can be adapted for different terrains or purposes, such as road cycling, mountain biking, or commuting.

While a kitten and a bicycle may seem quite different at first glance, there are interesting similarities when considering aspects like learning, independence, care, playfulness, and adaptability.

Second one: A bicycle and a food blender.

Certainly! Let's explore the analogy between a bicycle and a food blender:

1. Rotational Motion:
• Bicycle: Pedaling involves a circular motion, converting the rider's energy into rotational movement to propel the bicycle forward.
• Food Blender: The blades of a food blender also move in a circular motion, transforming ingredients into a blended mixture.
2. Mechanical Components:
• Bicycle: Both bicycles and food blenders consist of various mechanical components. In a bicycle, you have components like the chain, gears, pedals, and wheels.
• Food Blender: A food blender has mechanical parts such as blades, a motor, and controls, all working together to blend and process food.
3. Energy Input:
• Bicycle: The rider provides energy through pedaling, converting human power into kinetic energy for the bicycle's movement.
• Food Blender: Electricity powers a food blender, and the user's input is in the form of selecting settings and controlling the blending process.
4. Functionality:
• Bicycle: A bicycle serves as a means of transportation, fitness, and recreation.
• Food Blender: A food blender is used for processing and blending ingredients, creating various food and beverage items.
5. Control and Speed:
• Bicycle: The rider has control over the speed and direction of the bicycle, adjusting pace according to preference.
• Food Blender: Users can control the speed and duration of blending in a food blender, customizing the texture and consistency of the food.
6. Human Interaction:
• Bicycle: Requires human input and effort to operate and reach a destination.
• Food Blender: Involves human interaction to select ingredients, operate the controls, and create a desired food outcome.

While a bicycle and a food blender may seem unrelated at first, there are interesting parallels in terms of rotational motion, mechanical components, energy input, functionality, control, and human interaction.

Third one: A kitten and a clock.

Certainly! Let's explore the analogy between a kitten and a clock:

1. Curiosity and Exploration:
• Kitten: Kittens are naturally curious and explore their surroundings to learn about the world.
• Clock: Some clocks, especially traditional ones with visible gears, may attract the curiosity of people who are interested in how mechanisms work.
2. Playfulness:
• Kitten: Kittens are known for their playful behavior, engaging in activities that involve chasing, pouncing, and batting at objects.
• Clock: Some clocks, especially those with pendulums or moving parts, can be visually interesting and captivating, invoking a sense of playfulness in observers.
3. Rhythmic Behavior:
• Kitten: Kittens often exhibit rhythmic behaviors, such as kneading or purring.
• Clock: Clocks, particularly those with pendulums or tick-tock sounds, have a rhythmic and repetitive motion.
4. Learning and Development:
• Kitten: Like a clock, which is a tool for measuring time, kittens undergo developmental changes over time, growing and learning as they age.
5. Intriguing Movements:
• Kitten: The way a kitten moves, with its agile and sometimes unpredictable motions, can be intriguing to observe.
• Clock: The movements of clock hands or other features can be fascinating, especially in more elaborate timepieces.
6. Symbolism of Time:
• Kitten: Represents the passage of time through its growth and development.
• Clock: Symbolizes the measurement and passage of time in a more literal sense.

While a kitten and a clock may appear dissimilar, there are interesting connections in terms of curiosity, playfulness, rhythmic behavior, learning, intriguing movements, and the symbolic representation of time.

 

Fourth one: A Jack-in-the-box and the moon.

Let's explore the analogy between a Jack-in-the-box and the moon:

1. Element of Surprise:
• Jack-in-the-box: The main feature of a Jack-in-the-box is the surprise element when a figurine pops out unexpectedly when the lid is opened.
• Moon: The moon can be visually surprising, especially during events like a full moon or a lunar eclipse, capturing attention with its changing appearance.
2. Mechanical Interaction:
• Jack-in-the-box: Operates using a mechanical spring mechanism that triggers the surprise element.
• Moon: Has gravitational interactions with celestial bodies, causing phenomena like tides and gravitational influences on Earth.
3. Symbolism:
• Jack-in-the-box: Can symbolize unpredictability, fun, or a sudden change in a situation.
• Moon: Holds various symbolic meanings across cultures, representing mystery, cycles, and the passage of time.
4. Visual Presence:
• Jack-in-the-box: A physical toy with a distinct appearance that captures attention when it pops up.
• Moon: A celestial body with a prominent and captivating presence in the night sky, drawing attention to its phases and features.
5. Cyclical Nature:
• Jack-in-the-box: Can be closed and reset to repeat the surprise, creating a cyclical experience.
• Moon: Exhibits phases in a cyclical manner, transitioning from new moon to full moon and back.
6. Entertainment and Amusement:
• Jack-in-the-box: Designed for entertainment and amusement, especially for children.
• Moon: Inspires wonder and awe, often observed for its beauty and as a source of inspiration.

While a Jack-in-the-box and the moon may seem unrelated at first, there are intriguing connections in terms of surprise, mechanical interaction, symbolism, visual presence, cyclical nature, and their roles in entertainment and inspiration.

 

Fifth one: A clock and a sea anemone.

Let's explore the analogy between a clock and a sea anemone:

1. Rhythmic Movements:
• Clock: Clocks, especially those with pendulums or ticking sounds, often exhibit rhythmic and repetitive movements.
• Sea Anemone: Sea anemones can have rhythmic movements in the water, swaying with the currents or retracting and extending their tentacles.
2. Symbiotic Relationships:
• Clock: Operates independently or as part of a human-controlled system to measure and display time.
• Sea Anemone: Often engages in symbiotic relationships with other marine life, such as providing shelter for clownfish.
3. Mechanical and Biological Systems:
• Clock: Functions based on mechanical systems, such as gears and springs, for timekeeping.
• Sea Anemone: Operates as a biological organism with specialized cells and structures for survival and feeding.
4. External Interaction:
• Clock: External factors, like winding or setting, can influence its accuracy and function.
• Sea Anemone: Interacts with its environment, capturing prey or responding to changes in water conditions.
5. Adaptability:
• Clock: Can be designed for various environments and purposes, from wall clocks to wristwatches.
• Sea Anemone: Demonstrates adaptability to different marine environments, ranging from shallow reefs to deeper ocean floors.
6. Symbolic Significance:
• Clock: Symbolizes the measurement and organization of time in human societies.
• Sea Anemone: Holds significance in marine ecosystems and can symbolize resilience and adaptability in nature.

While a clock and a sea anemone may seem quite different, there are intriguing parallels in terms of rhythmic movements, symbiotic relationships, the interplay between mechanical and biological systems, external interaction, adaptability, and symbolic significance.

 

Sixth one:  A garbage heap and a submarine.

Let's explore the analogy between a garbage heap and a submarine:

1. Hidden Treasures:
• Garbage Heap: Despite being a collection of discarded items, a garbage heap might contain hidden treasures or items that can be recycled.
• Submarine: Submarines explore the depths of the ocean, often revealing hidden treasures like marine life, geological features, or sunken artifacts.
2. Environmental Impact:
• Garbage Heap: Represents the environmental impact of human consumption and waste, highlighting issues of pollution and sustainability.
• Submarine: Environmental awareness is crucial for submarines exploring the ocean, as they may encounter pollution, coral degradation, or other ecological challenges.
3. Concealed Complexity:
• Garbage Heap: While appearing chaotic, a garbage heap can contain complex compositions of various materials and items.
• Submarine: Submarines, despite their streamlined appearance, are complex machines with advanced technologies for navigation, propulsion, and life support.
4. Human Influence:
• Garbage Heap: Reflects human consumption patterns, waste disposal practices, and environmental responsibility.
• Submarine: Represents human exploration of the ocean and the technological advancements designed for underwater navigation.
5. Diversity of Contents:
• Garbage Heap: Contains a diverse range of items, from plastics to organic waste, showcasing the variety of materials discarded.
• Submarine: Explores the diverse ecosystems and marine life found in different ocean depths.
6. Challenges and Opportunities:
• Garbage Heap: Presents challenges in waste management but also opportunities for recycling and reducing environmental impact.
• Submarine: Faces challenges in exploring the ocean's depths but offers opportunities for scientific discovery, environmental monitoring, and resource exploration.

While a garbage heap and a submarine may seem dissimilar, there are interesting connections in terms of hidden treasures, environmental impact, concealed complexity, human influence, the diversity of contents, and the challenges and opportunities they present.

 

Seventh one: A submarine and a gourmet Chinese banquet.

Let's explore the analogy between a submarine and a gourmet Chinese banquet:

1. Precision and Detail:
• Submarine: Operates with precision in navigating the underwater environment, relying on detailed instrumentation and advanced technology.
• Chinese Banquet: Gourmet Chinese banquets often involve meticulous preparation and attention to detail in both presentation and flavors.
2. Layered Complexity:
• Submarine: Features multiple layers and compartments, each serving a specific function within the overall structure.
• Chinese Banquet: Gourmet banquets can consist of multiple courses, each contributing to the overall dining experience with its unique flavors and textures.
3. Culinary Technology:
• Submarine: Utilizes advanced technology for navigation, propulsion, and communication.
• Chinese Banquet: May involve advanced culinary techniques, such as precision cooking, intricate food arrangements, and artistic presentation.
4. Cultural Significance:
• Submarine: Represents advancements in naval technology and plays a role in national defense and exploration.
• Chinese Banquet: Holds cultural significance in Chinese traditions, often associated with celebrations, family gatherings, and special occasions.
5. Integration of Elements:
• Submarine: Integrates various components and systems to function as a cohesive unit underwater.
• Chinese Banquet: Integrates a variety of dishes, each contributing to the overall harmony of flavors and textures in the dining experience.
6. Attention to Aesthetics:
• Submarine: Designed with attention to both functionality and aesthetics, considering factors like hydrodynamics and stealth.
• Chinese Banquet: Emphasizes aesthetic presentation, with an emphasis on visually appealing dishes that engage the senses.
7. Experience and Exploration:
• Submarine: Offers a unique experience in exploring the depths of the ocean and conducting scientific research.
• Chinese Banquet: Provides a unique culinary experience, allowing diners to explore a variety of flavors and textures in each dish.

While a submarine and a gourmet Chinese banquet may seem unrelated, there are interesting connections in terms of precision and detail, layered complexity, culinary and technological advancements, cultural significance, integration of elements, attention to aesthetics, and the unique experiences they offer.

 

Eighth analogy: A helicopter and a Beethoven piano sonata.

Let's explore the analogy between a helicopter and a Beethoven piano sonata:

1. Dynamic Movement:
• Helicopter: Exhibits dynamic movement with the ability to hover, ascend, descend, and change directions swiftly.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Beethoven's piano sonatas often feature dynamic movements, with changes in tempo, volume, and intensity, creating a sense of musical motion.
2. Control and Precision:
• Helicopter: Requires precise control for takeoff, landing, and mid-air maneuvers.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Pianists must demonstrate control and precision in playing the intricate and expressive passages of a Beethoven piano sonata.
3. Variability in Sound:
• Helicopter: Produces varying sounds depending on its operations, from the rhythmic beating of rotor blades to engine noise.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Offers a diverse range of musical expressions, from soft and melodic to powerful and dramatic, showcasing the piano's versatility.
4. Technical Mastery:
• Helicopter: Pilots need technical mastery to operate the helicopter effectively, considering factors like altitude, speed, and navigation.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Pianists require technical proficiency to convey the complexities of Beethoven's compositions, mastering challenging fingerwork and interpretive nuances.
5. Artistic Expression:
• Helicopter: While primarily a machine for transportation, helicopters can be designed with artistic and aesthetic considerations.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Represents artistic expression in music, with Beethoven using sonatas as a medium for conveying emotions, stories, and creativity.
6. Innovation and Creativity:
• Helicopter: Symbolizes technological innovation in aviation and engineering.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Reflects Beethoven's creative innovation in classical music, pushing boundaries and evolving the sonata form.
7. Temporal Evolution:
• Helicopter: Moves through space in a dynamic and evolving manner.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Progresses through time, with movements unfolding in a structured yet evolving musical journey.
8. Sensory Experience:
• Helicopter: Offers a multisensory experience, involving visual observation and auditory perception.
• Beethoven Piano Sonata: Engages the senses through auditory perception, allowing listeners to experience the emotional depth and expressive qualities of the music.

While a helicopter and a Beethoven piano sonata may seem distinct, there are intriguing connections in terms of dynamic movement, control and precision, variability in sound, technical mastery, artistic expression, innovation and creativity, temporal evolution, and the sensory experiences they offer.

 

Nineth analogy: A novel by Tolstoy and a Mig fighter jet.

Let's explore the analogy between a novel by Tolstoy and a MiG fighter jet:

1. Epic Scale:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Known for writing epic novels with vast scopes, complex characters, and intricate plots, such as "War and Peace."
• MiG Fighter Jet: Often associated with high-speed aerial combat and military operations on a grand scale, reflecting an epic dimension in the realm of aviation.
2. Character Depth:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Tolstoy delves deep into the inner lives and motivations of characters, creating multifaceted personalities.
• MiG Fighter Jet: Despite being a machine, the MiG reflects the depth of engineering and design, with intricate systems and capabilities.
3. Historical Significance:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Tolstoy's works are often considered historically significant, providing insights into societal and political contexts.
• MiG Fighter Jet: MiG jets have played historic roles in military conflicts, contributing to the evolution of aviation technology and strategies.
4. Narrative Momentum:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Tolstoy's novels often have a narrative momentum, drawing readers into the unfolding story.
• MiG Fighter Jet: Possesses high-speed capabilities and agility, creating a sense of dynamic movement and momentum during aerial maneuvers.
5. Philosophical Reflections:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Tolstoy's novels often incorporate philosophical reflections on life, war, and human nature.
• MiG Fighter Jet: Represents the intersection of technology, strategy, and the philosophical considerations surrounding military power and defense.
6. Symbolic Representation:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Characters and events in Tolstoy's novels are often symbolic representations of broader themes and ideas.
• MiG Fighter Jet: Symbolizes military prowess, technological advancement, and national defense capabilities.
7. Cultural Impact:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Tolstoy's novels have left a lasting impact on literature, influencing subsequent generations of writers.
• MiG Fighter Jet: MiG jets have had a significant impact on military aviation and have become cultural symbols of strength and technological prowess.
8. Emotional Engagement:
• Tolstoy's Novel: Invokes emotional engagement through the development of characters and the exploration of human experiences.
• MiG Fighter Jet: Evokes emotions tied to patriotism, defense, and the awe-inspiring nature of aviation technology.

While a novel by Tolstoy and a MiG fighter jet may seem like disparate entities, there are interesting connections in terms of epic scale, character depth, historical significance, narrative momentum, philosophical reflections, symbolic representation, cultural impact, and emotional engagement.

 Note: The Chatster missed perhaps the most obvious similarity, the one I had in mind when I suggested the analogy, thinking I'd give it a freebee: They're both Russian.

Tenth analogy: A three-dimensional matrix and the Christian Trinity.

RESPONSE ONE, OF TWO 

Let's explore the analogy between a three-dimensional matrix and the Christian Trinity:

1. Structural Complexity:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: In mathematics or computer science, a three-dimensional matrix involves complex structures with multiple layers, rows, and columns.
• Christian Trinity: The Christian Trinity, consisting of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, represents a complex theological concept involving three distinct persons in one Godhead.
2. Unity in Diversity:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Comprises diverse elements that, when organized, contribute to the overall structure and function of the matrix.
• Christian Trinity: Emphasizes the unity of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit within the Christian doctrine, despite their distinct roles and characteristics.
3. Interconnectedness:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Elements within the matrix are interconnected, with changes in one dimension affecting the entire structure.
• Christian Trinity: Emphasizes the interconnectedness and mutual indwelling of the three persons of the Trinity, highlighting their inseparable nature.
4. Symbolic Representation:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Used as a symbolic representation of complex data or relationships in mathematical and computational contexts.
• Christian Trinity: Serves as a symbolic representation of the triune nature of God in Christian theology.
5. Multiplicity in Unity:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Demonstrates the concept of multiple dimensions coming together to form a unified whole.
• Christian Trinity: Represents the idea of three distinct persons existing in perfect unity within the Godhead.
6. Conceptual Abstraction:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Involves a conceptual abstraction to represent complex relationships or data structures.
• Christian Trinity: Requires conceptual understanding and theological reflection to grasp the mystery of the triune nature of God.
7. Infinite Nature:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Can theoretically extend infinitely in each dimension, depending on the context.
• Christian Trinity: Represents the infinite and eternal nature of the triune God.
8. Dynamic Interplay:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Involves dynamic interactions within its structure, with changes and transformations over time.
• Christian Trinity: Involves dynamic interplay and relational dynamics among the three persons of the Trinity.

While a three-dimensional matrix and the Christian Trinity may seem like disparate concepts, there are interesting connections in terms of structural complexity, unity in diversity, interconnectedness, symbolic representation, multiplicity in unity, conceptual abstraction, infinite nature, and dynamic interplay.

RESPONSE TWO, OF TWO

Let's explore the analogy between a three-dimensional matrix and the Christian Trinity:

1. Multidimensional Nature:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: In mathematics and computer science, a three-dimensional matrix has three axes (x, y, z), providing a multidimensional space for organizing and representing data.
• Christian Trinity: The Christian Trinity comprises three persons—Father, Son, and Holy Spirit—forming a theological concept that represents a multidimensional understanding of the divine.
2. Interconnectedness:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Elements in a three-dimensional matrix are interconnected through the intersections of the axes, creating relationships and dependencies.
• Christian Trinity: The three persons of the Trinity are interconnected in their divine nature, working together in harmony within the Christian doctrine.
3. Unity in Diversity:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Represents a unity of three dimensions, each contributing to the overall structure.
• Christian Trinity: Emphasizes the unity of the three persons in the Godhead, each distinct yet inseparable.
4. Symbolic Representation:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Often used as a symbolic representation of complex data structures and relationships.
• Christian Trinity: Symbolizes the complex yet unified nature of the divine, providing a framework for understanding God in Christian theology.
5. Comprehensive Understanding:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Enables a comprehensive representation of information, accounting for multiple aspects simultaneously.
• Christian Trinity: Offers a comprehensive understanding of the divine, incorporating the roles and relationships of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit.
6. Integration of Elements:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Integrates elements along each axis, contributing to the overall structure of the matrix.
• Christian Trinity: Integrates the three persons of the Trinity, each contributing to the divine essence and purpose.
7. Spiritual Geometry:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: In a metaphorical sense, the dimensions of a matrix can be seen as a form of spiritual geometry, organizing information in a structured manner.
• Christian Trinity: Reflects a spiritual understanding of God's nature, organizing theological concepts in a structured framework.
8. Holistic Perspective:
• Three-Dimensional Matrix: Encourages a holistic perspective by considering multiple dimensions simultaneously.
• Christian Trinity: Encourages a holistic understanding of God, considering the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit in unity.

While a three-dimensional matrix and the Christian Trinity operate in different realms—one in mathematics and the other in theology—there are intriguing connections in terms of their multidimensional nature, interconnectedness, unity in diversity, symbolic representation, comprehensive understanding, integration of elements, spiritual geometry, and holistic perspective.

 

Which of those various analogies made the most sense?

The assessment of which analogy makes the most sense is subjective and depends on individual perspectives and preferences. Each analogy draws connections between seemingly unrelated concepts, highlighting similarities in various aspects. The significance of an analogy may vary based on personal interests, experiences, and understanding of the involved concepts.

If you have a specific criterion or context in mind for determining the "most sense," please provide more details, and I can offer a more tailored response. Otherwise, the value of each analogy lies in its ability to illuminate interesting parallels between diverse concepts.

You see, the Chatster is thoroughly housebroke.

Which of those analogies is most like a kumquat?

Among the analogies discussed, none directly relates to a kumquat, as the analogies primarily involve diverse concepts such as animals, objects, and abstract ideas. However, if we consider the characteristics of a kumquat, such as its small citrus fruit nature, one could draw a loose analogy with the MiG fighter jet. This analogy is based on the idea that both the kumquat and the MiG fighter jet possess compact and concentrated features within their respective domains – one being a small fruit with intense citrus flavor and the other being a nimble and agile military aircraft. Keep in mind that this analogy is more creative and symbolic rather than being a direct and precise comparison.